Planets Tracker9 - Day 4 (2/9) - Mafia Win!

Why do you think this?

I understand why you think it’s true but why wouldn’t Gorta say it as either alignment?

It’s just him giving a comment on how he thinks wolves play.

Nothing stops mafia using the same Team member for all the kills.

So Tracker shouldn’t withold information if they catch someone redhanded.

It’s not like they can see any town PR visit anyway.

And game gets easier when a scum already flipped, even if it costs the only PR.

That’s my entire point? I don’t think a wolf was trying to do it deliberately to get towncred. And I also don’t think if a wolf misunderstood something about the setup they would go “I was joking but I’m not actually joking”

That looks like a Townie screwing up and trying to save face.

Idk well what do you think:
There is a feel of scum presence in the thread or someone mentions it.
Can there be two scum in people who weren’t in thread?

I mean yeah I get your point, it’s not like the read is set in stone, it’s basically the same strength as Brad’s Litten read but I see Gorta saying all that from town PoV more then so a Wolf PoV.
Mainly the last part.

Like the last post he made

They were actually joking?
also there is zero town credit for that like what?!?

Yes. I don’t see any reason why not.

I’m trying to understand your starting assumptions since they seem strange.

1 Like

Like where did they say they weren’t joking afterwards they WERE joking.

Your assumptions seem strange if you honestly think that’s credit worthy.

I’m using your words to make this as easy as possible for you to understand. But fundamentally they backed down, but not really.

That seems consistent with them feeling like they were looking foolish and wanting to back down from it but still confused about the setup. This seems like a decently villagery motivation. Do you agree?

1 Like

No I do not agree

What?

1 Like

Actually you know what upon further ISO re-read on Marluna I realized they were just curious on how a Tracker N0 would work that is it, so that’s NAI.

I wasn’t here for these posts but to me this clearly shows they’re still not entirely sure how the tracker works.

Why not?

Everyone knows how the tracker works.

They were asking if the tracker would receive a cop check or something for a N0 or else as I explained previously if it was just a simple track it would just be useless because mafia can’t attack N0.

1 Like

Alright, and how does that make my read invalid?

1 Like

I know how Tracker works…

The thing I don’t know how a Tracker with N0 results would work…

And since this game’s Tracker doesn’t have a N0 result I am leaning towards Lucky’s analysis.

Your town read on me looks weird…