I go with what the situation tells me.
So both.
hmmmmokay
I dunno, it’s kind of late and I’ve posted way more than I intended today tbh
I think the conclusion though is that Gorta!Town probably always?
?
1 Like
Thoughts from beancat!
-
There are no roles that can do anything at night in this game
I don’t know what signs everyone show when they are mafia, so this is going to be hard… -
I’m having trouble making sense of BradLand’s post #198. In that post, they accuse Eli of TMI and vote them. However, in the post that they are replying to, the_worst explicitly states that they “don’t see [the] motivation in wolves making that kind of post”. The_worst expressed confusion and did not accuse Eli, but BradLand says that the_worst “might be right” and attacks Eli. Can BradLand be mafia here, trying to exaggerate suspicion?
2a. It seems that WindwardAway pointed this out already in post #224! Looks like I’m on the right track. -
I don’t like the_worst townreading Trochi for “top secret” reasons
Not calling it mafia, I just don’t like it. -
In post #270, BradLand states that they townread/townlean four people, and think there is one (I assume this to mean “at least one” - correct me if I’m wrong) mafia in Gorta/Eli. How is it possible to have an idea on this many people’s alignments? The game has barely begun. I believe this post shows that Brad has information that the rest of us don’t (i.e. is mafia).
I read up until post 300! I will catch up on the rest of them in a little bit. Please leave any questions you guys have for when I return!
2 Likes
my townread on trochi is kind of awkward so i’m waiting to see how the game develops so i know if i’m right or not 
2 Likes
My home site was EpicMafia, which was primarily a chat mafia site, so we are in the habit of making snap reads in games, including forum mafia style.
We’ll make numerous reads early in the game and re-eval as the game goes on. Even if we plan on pulling back during the game we just end up outing reads, even if we simply post “(name) is town” because we have massive confidence in doing so.
1 Like
likely. independently i think it’s probably a non-deceptive mindset that responds to being called out for being performative by complaining about my playstyle rather than playing. :P
please only open this after gorta’s innocent child status has expired, because gorta is an innocent child!!!
i think there are worlds where Gorta is scum with a p low vibe team.
i have severely underestimated how annoying it would be to read posts with no glasses
3 Likes
eh i’d say strong reads that early aren’t likely but it’s definitely possible to look at a few of someone’s post and go yep towny shit or vice versa
i thought this was a joke when i saw it ngl worst was it legit
2 Likes
Hi Bean Katze
1 Like
well now i’m intrigued
are you saying that due to his team gorta feels the need to powerwolf in these worlds
oh don’t you say that i’ll dream cheat again and figure out it’s both a katze alt and mafia
weirdly dismissive in a kinda scummy way
feels like really really low effort shading
I might fall asleep soon, might not, either way that’s why I disappear if I do.
“(player) is good vote but (meme)” is >>> rand scum also, regardless of solic’s alignment
you weren’t meant to click that spoiler smh
more negging on our glorious ic
kiiiind of. i wouldn’t call what they’re doing, like, powerwolfing in any world. but more like their way of responding to prompts also makes sense if they’re trying to tread water in a fairly town-dominated gamestate.
this relies on a lot of people being town that i think are scum before gorta fwiw. just saying there’s this lil voice at the back of my mind telling me the IC!gorta thing isn’t a great idea.
frog would be like, a very difficult read in a scum!gorta if that helps qualify how abstract this is 
2 Likes
also if pinging eli every single time i need him to speak is the secret sauce to getting him to talk then so be it
3 Likes
i dont follow the logic here