Poor Approximations of Catgirls - Thread 1

[Hippopablompoyeetus]

Joining the wallpost hoes because I don’t want to be a schmuck who runs out of posts.

ISO’ing Arete and they mainly look bad just cuz they’re takes are super bland and it doesn’t really look like they are believeing what they are saying. If there are multiple mafia in vul/marshal/arctic/arete, cuz apparently everyone keeps talking about these pairings (which is weird tbh), it is deffo Arctic & Arete imo.

I really don’t like either of them individually and Arctic voted Arete in a “haha voting you but not expecting you to go over” kind of way and I still don’t think Arete is going over today.

Having said that its weird so many people are looking for W/Ws around that group and Wazza has not improved at all and is probably just mafia atp.

/Vote Wazza @Nyarchmage

If we don’t want Wazza, looking at voting in Arete,Wisdom,Arctic.

[nutella]

@Arctic

@nutella

i think the way he has discredited marshal’s v/w vul/arete read makes him >rand wolf with exactly one of vul/arete

i came back to this because i hadn’t read all the posts around this point but like, do you… actually think i’m likely to be aligned with arete/vulgard? i feel like i’m pretty obviously not aligned with either of those slots especially if you’ve been parsing our interactions thoroughly (which you claim to have done in this same post). though i guess the main reason for unaligning me from vulgard is probably vulgard’s treatment of me, which is probably missing in replies to my iso because i haven’t responded to half of his posts about me lol

i dont really know what to make of the way you use your scumread of me to fuel the arete/vul dichotomy, i want to say that it’s unlikely to come from a wolf because the surface level purpose of this post is to use my wolf flip to fuel your arete/vul pushes but a wolf would know i’m not flipping wolf. however, the reality is if i flip town the thread will probably erupt at arete/vul regardless and i seriously doubt it’d make you reconsider the reality of this dichotomy regardless of your alignment

yeah i don’t know about your vul interactions tbh, what i saw was pretty tame

and it’s fair to say i’m sort of doubling down on the dichotomy regardless, i just think it’s pretty likely by their thread positions and i thought you fit into it in a certain way but it’s more your treatment of marshal that concerned me individually

[JohnCarter]

This is a very good POE fmpov

Also I’m caught up

Not sure on my theory of Internet and Wind being linked now. For now I’ll invalidate it. Gth wind v atm fwiw. Unsure on internet.

[nutella]

@Arctic

i would be surprised if there are 0 in arete-marshal

i’m also considering the possibility of w/w at this point, because marshal’s main wolfreads this game have been me, vulgard and arete, and she’s gone through periods of hard pushing me and vulgard but largely kept the arete read on the backburner. i’m also not entirely sold on her reasoning for thinking she’s scum - yeah it’s okay to think arete’s reads are non-committal but the cited examples are like in their first post and nothing else. this also feels like a pretty reductive view of arete as a player, someone who’s prone to providing caveats for their reads regardless of aligmment ime and marshal should probably be aware of this?

this is a good point actually

[Arctic]

@Hippopablompoyeetus

I really don’t like either of them individually and Arctic voted Arete in a “haha voting you but not expecting you to go over” kind of way and I still don’t think Arete is going over today.

why is this wolfy that given when i placed my vote the level of confidence i had on the read was not at one where i considered arete to be obvious wolf enough to actually get votes, especially given the fact people just don’t like day1’ing stronger players in general

[nutella]

/vote Arete @Nyarchmage

meeting in the middle

[Kyubey]

I read through all of wind’s posted. From my point of view the only problem I have with their content so far is the fact that they as a player have not actively pushed their wolf reads and barely reference the person the people they vote whenever they post in the thread. If I was to look at the reaction test post and try to explain to myself why they made it - it comes off as a wolf who notices a wolf making fake posts and trying to brush it off in a joking way - which explains why they haven’t actually committed to an Arete wolf read unless I missed something in that ISO.

That said - I feel like that is the only mark against their slot, and I actually have liked some of their posts (as long as we ignore what they aren’t doing). I liked the way they handled pressure and I liked the way they town read Arctic and stated that no matter what Arctic read on them is, they think Arctic is town. FMPOV town reading someone in that way is something wolves are more hesitant about doing.

That goes out the window if they are aligned but I’m not gonna question that rn

[JohnCarter]

I think Nutella’s read on me is towny

Specifically the “jc is a town lean but nonsense about it being a weakish town read but still keep him alive”

Looks like a villa in the dark who’s wary of my wolf game and would probably expect wolf them to go harder in either direction

Maybe slightly conf biased given I liked their push and vote earlier but still :)

[Hippopablompoyeetus]

Voting a partener early D1 but not planning for them to go over is obviously common amongst wolves.

By saying “I do not expect this to go over” when voting Arete, you make it easy to not actually try make Arete go over eod without looking suspicous, because you’ll have just kept to the narrative you started from the vote.

Now i’ve written this it’s preflippy as hell lol, but I don’t like either of your slots anyway so im posting this lol

[Marshal]

@Arctic what is your read on me

I don’t want a long explanation just what it is and the basic rundown

[JohnCarter]

Who was it that outted IS as eevee? Because I think it’s true and I’d stipulate they’d look good should IS flip wolf based on how it went down (the wording of becaose or whatever)

Someone lmk otherwise I’ll check in 10 or so

[Mistyx]

how do you remember exactly how it happened without knowing who it was?

[JohnCarter]

Do you think you’ll ever get a productive answer to this other than “I remember the read and not who said it” because… because?

Lol

[Arctic]

@Hippopablompoyeetus

Voting a partener early D1 but not planning for them to go over is obviously common amongst wolves.

By saying “I do not expect this to go over” when voting Arete, you make it easy to not actually try make Arete go over eod without looking suspicous, because you’ll have just kept to the narrative you started from the vote.

Now i’ve written this it’s preflippy as hell lol, but I don’t like either of your slots anyway so im posting this lol

i can understand that perception from my initial vote
however i read over the segments again and then expressed itt that i deeply thought arete was mafia
i’m past my days of dogging on the thread to sheep me on everything, the sentiment i gave on arete at the time is the best you are going to get from me on day 1 when i think someone is mafia

[nutella]

@Mistyx

how do you remember exactly how it happened without knowing who it was?

tbf i also remember the becaose thing and not who said it lol

[Arctic]

i dont know.

[Mistyx]

me too i just wanted to see how he answered

[Arctic]

i remember pointing out it was eevee pretty early but i dont know if someone did this before me

i do recall vulgard saying he thought a similar thing but i pointed it out before him

[JohnCarter]

Why are you giving me a reaction test to a question with only 1 answer when you town read me?

[JohnCarter]

Feel free to not answer this

Cbf going back and forth rn