Poor Approximations of Catgirls - Thread 1

[Wisdom]

I wish you weren’t as tunneled on Marshal, Arete. I think you likely were wrong on that read.

[Wisdom]

This should be sheepable though.

/vote Squirrel @Nyarchmage

[BS4215]

Hi. Haven’t read up yet, will do now

[Wisdom]

Oh okay I see

[bladescape]

New person alright.

[Arctic]

@bladescape

Marshall/Illwei are both town, even if brief scrolling tells me Marshall thinks I got tmi’d wolf

can you elaborate

also who do you actually think is mafia atp

@WindwardAway

Nvm that last part
I just read more of the thread and Marshal might be town lol

i don’t think anything she’s posted is remotely out of her wolfrange and it’s not really difficult to fake spew reads

i’m going to need something else to outweigh arete’s legacy

[Arctic]

@bladescape

Oh yeah, Marshall is town.

@bladescape

What if I told you that Arete is not a wolf.

these were bladescape’s only mentions of arete/marshal

i don’t think it’s outting but at the same time i don’t understand how someone genuinely trying to solve the game could have ignored arete/marshal this hard when they were a major thread topic

if marshal is a villager then blade voting village squirrel with v/v/v wagons means nothing

[min]

I want to say that spew probably doesnt work very well this way unless pack wolves know who the lost wolf is

which i…doubt honestly?

if you want to find evidence on why you’re town, you need to use posts made by vulgard towards you

vulgard had tmi of the wolfteam, we dont know if the pack had tmi that vulgard was a lw

[min]

this means that whoever had “super clearing” interactions with vulgard that didnt actually involve vulgard throwing shade towards them slash appealing to them/etc shouldn’t be clearing considering the fact that wolves literally could’ve killed vulgard

which clearly meant they didnt know vulgard was as wolf, which means nobody is inherently clear for pushing vulgard unless vulgard has made slimy posts towards them in the first place

[min]

@Moonwink

What? Vulgard is a lost wolf. If I’m a wolf, I don’t know Vulgard is a wolf, nor does Vulgard know I am a wolf. How is this a thing? XD

vulgard does know the wolfteam if you are a wolf but you’re right in the fact you couldn’t know they were

im confused on why you’re using this argument when you used posts of yourself pushing vulgard as a way to spew yourself?

[min]

@Wazza

I trust Arctic for different reasons but I wasn’t impressed earlier

It’s literally pointless to try and show you’re spewed town unless you absolutely need to, especially when you quote 2-3 posts to prove your point when there’s an entire ISO to dissect.

try and spew others as town instead

you can be townread without going “BUT IVE BEEN SPEWWWED” which is unironic given the Pokemon mash I kept doing that shit but tbf people kept pushing me and I was annoyed

im in a much better spot this game LMAO, I guess It is the people who are kinda regarded as consensus null/scummy who do that

[min]

ironic*

[min]

show me this

[min]

this is just arguing that vulgard was in antispew the entire game since they started posting in thread…which I heavily disagree with.

[Arctic]

@Nyarchmage

Wandering Spirit (Passive) - If you can get a dead Mafia member to guess in dead chat that you are a traitor/lost wolf/recluse/similar descriptive term for a Mafia member who is not part of the main team, you will join the Mafia team chat.

the pack didn’t know vulgard was lw otherwise this mechanic makes literally no sense

plus mafia probably killed him anyway

[min]

@Arctic

@Vulgard

marshal/JC are probably not W/W because of how marshal framed her read on me, but both their reads on me have been bad, and I have consistently disagreed with their direction

i feel like this random not w/w read out of context looks bad for marshal but i don’t think there is a logical reason for thinking this lol

anyway, i still don’t see what point you’re trying to make here especially because whether vulgard was trying to be massively correct or massively wrong is irrelevant for your slot, since he has you somewhere around the middle in a “probably one here” grouping

trying to argue he is entirely correct or entirely wrong just feels like a waste of time to me

@nutella

@Vulgard

JC/marshal has a wolf but probably not together.

@Arctic i had the same thought re the jc/marshal stuff from this snippet also

im agreeing

[min]

@Moonwink

Correct, but what I’m saying is that MY posts, MY push, MY reasons for criticizing Vulgard do NOT come from any alignment except for town. Whatever association you see between Vulgard and me that was created by Vulgard was either intentionally FAKED or unintentionally made.

fwiw I think this is towny

I disagree heavily with a lot of moonwink’s argument (especially considering the amount of derps it has) but I found her iso villagery d1 and I genuinely think her worldview consists of herself with a large percentage of these posts today being her practically begging to be spewed town

I think she wouldn’t be trying this hard as a wolf but that is my opinion

[Arctic]

@min

I think she wouldn’t be trying this hard as a wolf but that is my opinion

the points they were trying to argue were rubbish but it felt like they believed them

the problem is they could be a wolf who genuinely believes vulgard didn’t make them look worse

[min]

@Millium

I think its just unfair to be like, “Ya Vulgard is trying to ping his buddy”
and then every response made by Moonwink, to defend themselves is met with, “This is just wifom, hearsay”

like I guess they could just ignore it and keep solving, but people dont tend to naturally do that

edit: fixed grammar

this feels weh

because the argument in general is not the fact vul has bad spew with moon imo

its that interactions of moon pushing vul aren’t clearing when pack doesnt know vulgard is a wolf, not to mention I think spew reading is inherently unfair, because it genuinely is a huge hit or miss when people can very obviously antispew constantly at any point yet that doesnt dissolve the fact wolves still do have spew

[min]

@Arctic

the points they were trying to argue were rubbish but it felt like they believed them

the problem is they could be a wolf who genuinely believes vulgard didn’t make them look worse

I didnt even think of the second part