Poor Approximations of Catgirls - Thread 1

[Marshal]

I’d be down to argue it but I don’t really see you changing your mind if you are interpereting vuls posts in an entirely different way

I ftr think it is very likely town killed vul, so I could see the argument he did signal to wolves and they did catch it but even then I think his posts are more or less just trying to help the wolves along with their agenda instead of trying to signal because I think it’s very traceable if he actually does in a way wolves can find and know he knows that.

[alana]

I will be multitabling in a day too haha

[LASERpointer]

@Marshal

I ftr think it is very likely town killed vul

Okay, if you’re going with this and the team did catch onto Vulgard, who does that implicate fypov?

[Arctic]

@Marshal

also I think it still makes marl look worse with how he immediately went from “Marshal is town town town” to “kill marshal if arete v” and think his shift makes perfect sense in the world where he wants to kill whoever of me/arete is left instead of being forced into defending me. I also kinda think wolves just wanted me to die more that day so marl flipping makes more sense there too.

the thing is he didn’t do that
i just looked at his posts and he only went from thinkng you were locktown to thinking arete was town and then voting you, this “kill marshal if arete v” doesn’t exist

because im ngl i think pushing marl here is exactly the angle you take as a wolf since and i’m pretty sure this is in line with what arete was saying you’d do iirc

@Marshal

because I wasn’t wrong on, like, literally everything we know so far

where have you been correct that arete was wrong

@LASERpointer

this isn’t how I think she reacts as wolf after being on the receiving end of an Arete tunnel.

how do you think she would react as a wolf then

[Marshal]

@Marshal

I think it’s very traceable if he actually does in a way wolves can find and know he knows that.

Which is also a thing I think points to hippo v

@Hippopablompoyeetus

Howling. Alone. Sad.
I search for my pack in vain:
Am wet dog in rain.

• Hippobampoyeetus

@Vulgard

this is a lost wolf soft

he has to know if he ever dies this post will be brought up and scrutinized
to a degree its WiFoM but I think this is a red herring post. Kinda weird nobody has tried to use it against hippo but that doesn’t change this post

[Marshal]

@Arctic

@Marshal

because I wasn’t wrong on, like, literally everything we know so far

where have you been correct that arete was wrong

JohnCarter and Vulgard.

[Marshal]

@LASERpointer

@Marshal

I ftr think it is very likely town killed vul

Okay, if you’re going with this and the team did catch onto Vulgard, who does that implicate fypov?

I don’t think the team did catch on to vulgard per se and just thought he was a wolfsiding townie unless they had some sort of mechanical info.

[Marshal]

@Arctic

i just looked at his posts and he only went from thinkng you were locktown to thinking arete was town and then voting you, this “kill marshal if arete v” doesn’t exist

also its literally his last post what

@Vulgard

if this flips town kill marshal tomorrow
don’t just forget about arete’s case like people love to forget legacies

Nya nya ah ah ah

[Marshal]

@Marshal

@Vulgard

if this flips town kill marshal tomorrow

don’t just forget about arete’s case like people love to forget legacies

Nya nya ah ah ah

this also kinda TMIs arete in hindsight but lol

[Hippopablompoyeetus]

what Is happening my feLlow kIds.

I feel liKe wE are proBabloy gonnA hanG anothEr viLlager today and should probably just hang MarShal today for wagonomics

assuming both vul and JC were NK’d by scum which is absoultely most likely i think mafia want to make it so they are loudest voices in thread tbh

[Marshal]

OH you were talking about marl

marl liked that vul post @Arctic

[Marshal]

I said that in my post about marl

i didn’t think it was that bad but literally right after he is begging vul not to kill me because I am always town he likes that post from vul saying to kill me if arete flipped v which is ?nya?

[Arctic]

i didn’t really get this impression from his treatment of you and it generally felt a lot more muted than his treatment of me and JC

i’m also not looking at all of his posts as though he was trying to signal, it just happened to be that in the post i suspected he was signalling to you he also used it to accuse you of something which he didn’t really push you much for which i think indicates w/w

[LASERpointer]

@Arctic

how do you think she would react as a wolf then

Nyat like this! I think a wolf in her spot goes mental trying to misspew anyone possible and set up associationsunder the assumption that she’s the yeet (because the legacy of town!Arete is invaluable to listen to). Instead, she appears to be trying to solve the same in a genuine fashion.

[Arctic]

uhh… no
arete’s posts at eod indicated they still thought JC was town, and your last posts about JC were doubting your townread on him

as for vulgard, from wolves’ point of view he was town so trying to argue that they would want you dead more for being correct by suspecting vulgard doesn’t really work

so both of these are. uh. wrong

[Hippopablompoyeetus]

@Marshal

@Hippopablompoyeetus

Howling. Alone. Sad.

I search for my pack in vain:
Am wet dog in rain.

• Hippobampoyeetus

@Vulgard

this is a lost wolf soft

he has to know if he ever dies this post will be brought up and scrutinized
to a degree its WiFoM but I think this is a red herring post. Kinda weird nobody has tried to use it against hippo but that doesn’t change this post

Actually Vul would have replied to a lost wolf haiku as lost wolf regardless of who posted it.

Plus if I actually was GS and used that haiku to LW hunt i would have noticed that Vul was the only person who interacted with it and assuing mafia killed Vul they wouldnt have if i was on team.

[Marshal]

@Arctic

he also used it to accuse you of something which he didn’t really push you much for

He didn’t push me but he tried very very hard to discredit my reads and supress them. Making the thread think i’m mafia and therefore my reads worthless is very much in the realm of what LWgard would want to do.

[Marluxion]

Okay if vulgard knew who the Mafia were it means Marshal is actually probably town and I was right that both arete and Marshal were town

[Arctic]

@LASERpointer

Nyat like this! I think a wolf in her spot goes mental trying to misspew anyone possible and set up associationsunder the assumption that she’s the yeet (because the legacy of town!Arete is invaluable to listen to). Instead, she appears to be trying to solve the same in a genuine fashion.

it is not hard for a wolf like marshal to disguise agenda as genuine solving
you should know this

@Marshal

He didn’t push me but he tried very very hard to discredit my reads and supress them. Making the thread think i’m mafia and therefore my reads worthless is very much in the realm of what LWgard would want to do.

again i feel like you’re overstating how uncharitable his treatment of you was
wolves have to distance to an extent and this is at the level of what i’d expect for at least some partners
he never really tried to get you killed until his last few posts which i do think look good for you but meh

[alana]

you first said that if you were mafia you would have just nightkilled him instead of psuhing him?

not sure why this should clear you

that being said I don’t agree with the suspicions on you I think scumreading someone just for the Vulgard flip rather than on play is bad. feel like on play you are very null tbh