Poor Approximations of Catgirls - Thread 1

Fun fact the total post count will decrease each day as people die

Wouldnt stop people from jusy making walls of posts though.

I personally feel like post caps are BS because they are not only suffocating but also they actually can be circumvented when you think about it

your solve is wrong and you’re repping the position that if you are town, you can basically just sit back and coast for a few days because obviously it’s correct, obviously your reasons are good

Don’t think I’ve ever sat back and coasted even with my most comfortable solves but ok

I just feel like her mentioning it like she was able to tell was ?? because i got her to vote with me at lylo??

Please scrutinize me. <3 I am, and have been, open to scrutiny all game. If you think I haven’t been scrutinized please do it or get someone else to do it. So far, when I’ve felt like certain people today haven’t received much scrutiny, I’ve gone out of my way to ISO and find stuff to talk about to get a better read on them (see my interactions with Night and Min in particular earlier, as well as my posts about Hippo and Alana). :3 I don’t simply say they haven’t received much scrutiny.

takeaways from checking alana meta:

  • her reads look similar as both alignments. the main difference i found is that she gives fewer early thoughts as mafia, and they’re often centered around defending people / questioning the reads of others, rather than giving reads on people.
  • she solves more early on as town. consistently across these games, i had the thought that town alana takes a more active role in solving, earlier. it’s possible that some of this can be attributed to differences between mafia cafe and our site; our site features a lot of posts, especially this game. but alana hasn’t said anything like “there are too many posts,” so i don’t feel like she has a problem with this.
  • can’t be read on posting frequency/presence. i found alana’s posting frequency and presence equal as both alignments. i can’t determine if she has a postcount tell, because i haven’t found a way to check people’s postcounts in a game on mafia cafe, but by posting frequency, she seems unpolarized and more dependent on irl than anything. this is my least confident conclusion, but i do still think it applies.

based on these cliffs, i actually think alana’s a wolf here, specifically for her early-game approach. it seems much closer to how she plays as mafia than to how she plays as town.

@alana if something about your play got lost on me while i was checking your posts on mafia cafe, do tell. but i don’t think i’ve missed anything significant, unless it has to do with your long-term play.

what makes you town in this game?

3 Likes

Gimme a spicy wagon to join then. :3 I simply joined Squirrel-wagon because I was bored at the time.

did u read school of rock

i honestly don’t think i’ll be able to do that today, with less than 20 posts left and the inability to be around at eod. i’m just hoping you receive more attention tomorrow and/or from other slots today.

Marshal

writing a case now

i read the four games alana linked in this thread earlier, here:

Summary

i guess “read the four games” is an overstatement. i didn’t read everything, but i did read alana’s posts around the early-game, because i found them most applicable to the current gamestate (it’s the early-game, so i wanted to read her early-game)

sadge

i was in watership showdown tho!!!

school of rock is one of my favorite scumgames i played

JC and Mist both know me well enough to feed Min the content needed in that ISO dive to pocket me. There are certain things in it that kinda pinged me as either 1.) really astute of Min to pick up on, or 2.) coming from JC or Mist.

Alright. I’m townreading Marshal at the moment, but

/vote Marshall @Nyarchmage

prediction of the future that i made earlier today

hardclaim clairvoyant

4 Likes

Why didn’t I receive much of your focus today just out of curiosity? And why won’t I receive much tomorrow from you if you’re alive?

i’m saving my last 15 posts for immediate responses to questions / points of interest
i will not be around at eod
i still think jc is a wolf and don’t plan to unvote him

if i implied that, it was unintentional
i do plan to read you, but it’ll have to be tomorrow
and you didn’t receive much of my focus today, because you’re less familiar to me than most people here, and your posts haven’t stood out to me as much as the posts of several other slots (which is part of the reason why i’m calling for scrutiny on your slot)

oh yeah i actually have one more question
do you have literally anything to say about my meta assessment of alana
you just implied you’d played with her before. so you should be able to engage with that

Alright, alright.

I do feel like I’ve received some scrutiny from some slots (Nutella earlier, Night at various points in the game, Min and Illwei early D1). Min eventually turn their read around on me later on after they read my ISO earlier. I think Wisdom has been suss of me. Arete outright refused to give me a townread on me in spite of making a good point with regard to my attempts to interact with the people who he didn’t include in their readslist.

I guess I’m just confused about who you are concerned about not scrutinizing me enough? Was there anyone in particular you were worried about?