Poor Approximations of Catgirls - Thread 1

Forum Games Completed
,
#9793

Okay caught up.

First of all @Millium if you tend to get incredibly frustrated everytime you get suspected, try to learn to take a breather before you start typing. It’s a core part of the game so it’s important that you learn to handle it. What you did to min was both toxic and mean and completely unnecessary. They did nothing but play the game.

We seem to have moved past it but I needed to get it out because I’m afraid of people voting Millium for thread health rather than wolf reads. Like really, the wolf read came from “look this is made to redirect my mason guess” which it clearly wasn’t.

#9794

Second of all Marshal’s claim is nice but full of holes.

The most glaring one is “why didn’t I guess Squirrel?” Well, because according to her story this would only have happened on a night where only town died. So she knew she had to guess 4 townies. But she wolf read Squirrel, right? So there’s no way her reaction to the flips was “Why didn’t I guess Squirrel” when there’s an obvious answer to this: She wolf read her, so why would she guess Squirrel?

Another one is the whole “I was toxic towards Arctic and told vig to shoot me in EoD2 because I wanted to ??? Make Wolves Think I Was Another Role ???” this makes no sense whatsoever. In no world do I believe that all of the D2 stuff was intentional. She’s acting like she knew the n2 kills would have town kills only and her ability would be activated. How could she have been so sure about that, consider town have killing pr’s? And the most likely thing was that she was going to die, killed by town vig, which is something she doesn’t even acknowledge.

My final point is the one that’s bugging me the most. It’s about the n1 Alana death. Alana targeted Marshal, messed up her fake claim and died. Despite Marshal having a ton of thoughts and “this was my real thoughts and intentions all along” she doesn’t even bring up the fact wolves targeted her night 1. If she did a lot of shenanigans to cover her grounds, she would also know there’s a chance wolves already knew who she were since it’s proven she’s been targeted. Yet this thought never seem to have crossed her mind. Why did wolves target her if she’s town, and why hasn’t she mentioned it in her big reveal?

Lots of perspective slips here. I strongly believe this is a made up story trying to make past things look like stuff they were not. She wasn’t prepared for Squirrel dying because that was a town motivated kill, hence her biggest slip was that one since she wasn’t able to plan it properly.

3 Likes
#9795

Tldr

/vote Marshal

@Nyarchmage

#9796
TARGET VOTES VOTED BY
Millium 4/8 Illwei (#9614); Marshal (#9580); min (#9586); nightingale (#9662)
Marshal 5/7 bladescape (#8040); Mistyx (#7698); Wisdom (#9795)
Illwei 2/8 Kyubey (#8206); Moonwink (#9769)
Not Voting 6 BS4215; Hippopablompoyeetus; LASERpointer (#9402); Millium; Wazza (#9526); WindwardAway
#9797

i dont think it was planned, too many weird parts and holes

it looks more like trying to abuse information overflow caused by 4 deaths caused to push even weirder claim around. people see weird things happen, people are more likely to believe weird things right afterward

thats spec chat take 2

3 Likes
#9798

I bet the Millium wagon made Arete turn in their grave.

2 Likes
#9799

I’m still fine with flipping Marshal but not this early in the day

#9800

Valid. Let’s hammer at 10k lol

2 Likes
#9801

wait, you said you targeted marl with motion detector
marl died?

chloe was the kill???
before they joined game???

#9802

I could have been blocked.
Or I could have targeted him with something else that makes sense for the message to not change.
It’s up to the wolf to decide how they wanna soup me.

#9803

Yeah I’m still fpsing, I don’t think full claims is great.

#9804

soup?

#9805

Some people here said the anti claim mechanism was a soup thing where wolves could guess people’s roles until they were wrong and then they died. Hence I’m fpsing my claims a bit until it’s relevant again.

What I did or didn’t do tonight has no relevance, it’s nothing weird about it but there’s no point reading into it.

#9806

Idk, I think the anticlaim is just a vanillizer so far

#9807

I think maybe Marl’s role swap happened at EoD or as an instant thing, and not at the end of the night when kills were processed. That’s the only way I can think of that Chloe could’ve joined the game before dying; otherwise Marl would’ve died as a VT.

#9808

For clarification:
Instant actions weren’t blocked by the delay. They actually processed instantly, as far as I can tell, so the only actions that were delayed were the ones that process at the end of night.

#9809

Pretty sure Moonwink is town, reading her latest posts

#9810

That just makes a mass claim ideal though. Lots of ICs

#9811

True
Wolves would claim to be vanillized, too, though, if that were the case

#9812

What if the anticlaim mechanic changes every night? Like if it’s a vanillizer one night, and it’s a vig on another night, then changes to a roleblock?
I know this is a weird thought but I can’t help wondering why nobody claimed to be vanillized on N1 when someone did get vanillized on N2.