Poor Approximations of Catgirls - Thread 1

[Arctic]

@Marluxion

@Millium

And marl liked a post in which I said to shoot him

I did no such thing. I liked a post in which you said to shoot me if Marshal is wolfing here. That’s just how confident I am she isn’t.

copypasta spotted
this means marshal has to be a wolf right

@Wazza

Specifically your sudden read on me felt like forced confidence, as if you had 100% caught a guaranteed wolf, that’s the main thing I’m reading it from, I’d quote some posts in particular but you can find them yourself as I don’t have much time to go witchhunting for them atm.

i relapsed
i dont intend for that to happen again

@Wazza

I feel like when I saw Arete while I was in the thread they were constantly on a broader spectrum which gave me reminders to the first FoL game on the new site, I don’t exactly remember them being tunnelvisioned or anything remotely close to that though, apart from I guess they didn’t seem to care about changing their thoughts too much.

it’s not really that they’ve been tunneled
it’s just that i think they would have made more of an effort to get a better view on the game as a whole and work harder to convince thread on their position (on stuff other than Just Marshal), and most of their reads have felt stilted with me and wisdom being the best examples. the stuff on me openwolfing either just didn’t feel genuine, it felt like something arete felt they had to say because they’d be expected to read into it as town but i think they’d be aware in the context it really meant nothing
the only instance of them actually changing their mind from a real-time interaction i saw was with marl, but like i said at the time that just felt like a backtrack after they realized how they misread the room with how villagery marl was actually being

i’m not confident i was before because looking at their iso (which i actually hadn’t done yet, lolme) it’s not as terrible as i had remembered, but the lack of villageriness (which normally isn’t a problem from town arete) makes me still feel okay about the read

@Wazza

These things do not seem to really line up, you say my posts are villagery but you don’t like how I’m approaching this game? In what way? You explained why you don’t like it, but in what way is it disliked, I’m confident in the JC thing but not to a degree where I need to vote him out at the current moment (mainly since I doubt anyone would go along with it to begin with)

i literally explained my read on you in that post, your recent posts were villagery but overall i do not like your stiffness as a whole

@Wazza

I wanted to see if she’d bring you back up into the equation since I feel like you two just dropped away from each other suddenly and I didn’t like it at all, it gave me T/W or T/T vibes (and I hate these type of reads).

i don’t think this is true at all at least from my side, most of my posts have been about arete/marshal tbh

@Hippopablompoyeetus

Can someone else read this am i mad or do the quotes here not at all add up to the summary

no it doesn’t add up but i don’t think blatantly misinterpreting that is AI
probably

[Illwei]

I remember you in school of rock but not in the jester game. I got tunneled on Wisty and pretty much ig-

oh.

No i remember you

you were obvtown and got into a thunderdome with Seanzie right

when it was obvioius both of you were v

yeah i think

[Millium]

/vote Windward

@Nyarchmage

Don’t ask me why, cause I don’t know

[Wisdom]

Heading out soon.

Someone got questions?

[nightingale]

when i was
a young nya
my father
took me into the city
to se ea marching band

[Millium]

/vote Marshal

@Nyarchmage

[Wisdom]

People I doubt I’m wrong on being town:
Bladescape
Arctic
Vulgard

People that in addition seems likely to be town:
Wazza
Marluxion
WindwardAway
Squirrel
InternetStranger

Still think has some wolf equity (not in order):
Nutella
JohnCarter
Mistyx
Nightingale
Marshal
Arete

Feels like I’m missing a lot of people. Don’t have a read on min, millium, illwei or the neutral-but-maybe-not. Hippo’s push on me is kind of weird and could be an attempt to save w!arete, don’t understand it otherwise.

I’m STILL missing people? Ugh don’t really who that is.

[Wisdom]

Alana gut w
Laser no idea
Moonwink gut v

[Wisdom]

Good night, have a fun EoD! o/

[Arete]

hirete

I haven’t fully caught up on overnight stuff but I skimmed pings and also read Marshal’s-Iso-since-last-night

@Arctic

@Arete

yeah okay I just very-lightly-skimmed Squirrel’s Iso and he’s not actually wolfy, he’s just being Squirrely

and lowposting I guess but idt that’s super AI for him

can we stop having these wagons, which suck, and instead have different wagons, which don’t suck

@Arete why did you say this when wazza was still a wagon and you wolfread her

Squirrel and I were tied for top wagon and a couple votes ahead of Wazza, when I said ‘the wagons’ I meant ‘me and Squirrel’ and wasn’t including Wazza

@Arctic

also what is your marl read now

he Felt Town when I was in the thread with him last night

I would not assign super high amounts of confidence there

also I don’t think he’s w/w with Marshal, he’s a gutsy wolf but I think not nearly gutsy enough to declare that Marshal is 100% town

he has a lot of reads that don’t make sense to me but that’s pretty normal so it’s not a point against him

@Arctic

i read over vulgard’s wallpost again and i’m locking him town for at least the next 3 phases
the vibes, the sentiment, the emotion
it reminds me of my wallpost in hydra popcorn where i expressed my contempt for the (incorrect) consensus and begged for the^3 to shoot seth/sonic instead of cheese
it comes from someone who truly believes they are being wrongfully drowned out and ignored rather than someone who is trying to push agenda against the consensus and failing, because the focus is on “you should have listened to me” rather than “you ought to do this now”

good take

also Marshal is still a wolf, a couple posts that I found specifically bad were:

@Marshal

Well they say a lot of things that are, like, blatantly untrue and only work to make me look bad

@Marshal

Also I’m not ghosting you on finding specific things in their wall that is wrong when it is genuinely just, like… all of it. I feel like I have better things to do with my time and quoting on mobile sucks, I feel like nobody would read it, if you want I can give you the runthrough in general of why it sucks but not specifics

this is false, like I realize that I’m in a position to /know/ that it’s false but if she really believes that it’s false explaining why actually what she was doing was totally different from what I’m saying, or totally makes sense from a villager perspective, should not be hard (this is a weaker point because she did do a similar thing in UPick)

@Marshal

If arete is town i’m gonna be a little :) about literally everything they’ve said and will lose a super large amount of respect for their town game but I truly do not disrespect arete enough to think they could be town and are posting like they are

and this I think is a post that Marshal just never makes as town, like, she’s trying to use OOG factors (her respect for me) to guilttrip me into not scumreading her and I don’t think villa Marshal ever does that (it is also maybe trying to set up an argument tomorrow like ‘oh, Arete was just playing so badly, that’s the reason I suspected them, definitely not because I was powerwolfing’)

and I am separately incredibly confused about why Marl is saying that Marshal is 100% town, like, her posts since last night have basically just been ‘Arete is LOCKWOLF for pushing me’ (which she could maybe incorrectly believe as town as well, but it’s not villagery)

[Hippopablompoyeetus]

@Moonwink

I get that a lot of ‘game solvers’ don’t really know how to play D1, but most of them I think are aware that it’s nearly impossible to reliably solve the entire team D1. I think you threw the ‘1 wolf in me + Night’ take into your solve just to make your solve look more complete. However… it’s only D1. It looks more ‘try-hard’-y than anything, and not in a good way.

this is a rlly interesting read but idk why

just wanna draw attention to it

[Hippopablompoyeetus]

also im back catching up on thread just slightly less sober now

[Hippopablompoyeetus]

@alana

I think John Carter and Vulgard is TvT

same

[nutella]

@Illwei

I think arete is town but ok

Alana is my top town probably by far

why alana and why by far?
what do you think of mist strongly townreading you for “using the thread as a chatroom”? do you think your play so far is deserving of being strongly townread?

[Arete]

I think there is a good chance I go over today regardless of what I do because multiple of the people on my wagon have stated that they’re going to be asleep at EoD so I’m planning to just focus on making really good legacy reads

are there any people that anyone here would feel especially likely to actually listen to me on and not just ignore, I can prioritize getting a good read on those people

[Hippopablompoyeetus]

@Moonwink

If I’m a wolf though, I’ve got partners – partners who are ‘overlooking’ me and/or encouraging others to overlook me. Who do you think they could be? You mentioned already that people are overlooking me in general. Do you think the people NOT overlooking me could just be town? :3

ftr i really hate the defense of “oh yeah, if im mafia then who I am parteners???”

Someone can easily find you scummy in tone or reads or whatever completely isolated from other people, esp D1 with no flips.

I make this defense a lot as mafia but I have seen town make it before so I’m unsure how AI it is, but it’s definately not a good defense D1 and probably? lends to scum.

[Kyubey]

@Marshal

If arete is town i’m gonna be a little :) about literally everything they’ve said and will lose a super large amount of respect for their town game but I truly do not disrespect arete enough to think they could be town and are posting like they are

What exactly did I miss that caused this reaction? I don’t think Arete was disrespectful to you this game.

[nutella]

@Arete

I think there is a good chance I go over today regardless of what I do because multiple of the people on my wagon have stated that they’re going to be asleep at EoD so I’m planning to just focus on making really good legacy reads

are there any people that anyone here would feel especially likely to actually listen to me on and not just ignore, I can prioritize getting a good read on those people

read on mist?

[min]

ive been nonexistent today but I am willing to hear some takes if u dont mind, id rather have something to go off from in the case were wrong today

[Millium]

I always here people out