Poor Approximations of Catgirls - Thread 1

[Wazza]

This vote sucks
Not the player
Your reasoning

[Mistyx]

/vote Squirrel2412 @Nyarchmage

[Wisdom]

Okay but give me a reason to town read you now, you’ve procrastinated it enough ^^

[Mistyx]

i will not and you can blame wazza

bye

[Wazza]

Shrug
as long as you don’t execute me, you’re good

[Mistyx]

you’re probably a villager for this but i hate everything about how you’ve handled this

[Squirrel2412]

eh
I’m pretty sure we just flip between those two today
the longer you procrastinate resolving that dichotomy the worse it gets

regardless if you think I’m wolfy getting me out isn’t worth it
I have no thread influence whatsoever and figuring out which of the two is the wolf should be the priority

[Nyarchmage]

TARGET	VOTES	VOTED BY
Arete	8/12	Arctic (#1362); LASERpointer (#3152); Marluxion (#3667); Marshal (#3019); min (#3544); nutella (#3772); Squirrel2412 (#3800); Vulgard (#3767)
Wazza	3/12	Hippopablompoyeetus (#2824); JohnCarter (#166); Millium (#3670)
Squirrel2412	5/12	bladescape (#2877); Mistyx (#3802); nightingale (#2895)
Marshal	2/12	Arete (#3398); WindwardAway (#3463)
Marluxion	1/12	Moonwink (#3605)
Wisdom	1/12	Kyubey (#3541)
InternetStranger	1/12	Illwei (#2524)
nightingale	1/12	Wazza (#3753)
Not Voting	3	alana; InternetStranger; Wisdom (#3420)

[Wazza]

Apologies for that, but if I’m useless, I gotta use my stuff somewhere

[Arctic]

@Wazza

Talking about that though, what are your reads on Marshal, Arete and myself? I’m including the first two since I can’t help but feel they’re going to become a vocal point today and I’ll probably get thrown in there at some point for no reason, but also I need to see how your read has developed on me and Marshal specifically.

i just realized this post also asked for my read on you

i think these recent posts explaining your reads have easily been your most villagery, but on a macro level i still don’t really like how you’re approaching the game. i know you don’t solve like most people but the attachment to the JC read and focus on solving around defence just didn’t feel like you were trying to use your time productively to get a grasp on the game. your recent posts have helped to assuage this concern wrt to the JC progression, but i’m still not really sold so i’d probably have you somewhere around null/nullscum

@JohnCarter

Would be surprised if the bottom 5 didn’t have 4 wolves.

are you really that supremely confident in your mafia abilities to believe this lol

---

i read wind’s wallpost responses to kyubey
i’m feeling a bit better on her being town now
her transparency talking about her treatment of me feels genuine and unstilted, and her other responses to kyubey’s concerns were more no-nonsense and relaxed than i’d expect from wolf her given the heat she’s had already

---

@Mistyx

i started reading the case in detail and it actually reminded of me of why i was townreading marshal in the first place

i liked a ~lot of the way she was pushing her early reads, wrt like, how her confidence ebbed and flowed and how she was reacting to people’s takes on her pushing arctic/vul

@nutella i saw you floating the possibility of marshal/mist w/w but i don’t think it’s likely

imo this is too chad of a post to make about marshal as partners. imagine reading someone’s wallpost scumcase on your partner and being like “actually it reminded me why i townread them” lmao. this is just one micro thing, but in the reverse direction, marshal’s read on mist feels too whiteknighty/in your face to be on a wolf partner especially when it’s being leveraged as a point against arete (marshal saying arete should be townreading mist by now) - that sort of thing is blatantly unpartnered since wolf!marshal’s arete case is the crutch of her play and she’d be careful not to invalidate it in this way

@Wazza

Marsha, who do you want to flip?

um
have you been paying attention to anything
i’m almost inclined to say out of your wolfrange because wolf you would be paying much more attention to the state of the game given that you’re still a wagon option lol

[nutella]

@Arctic

@nutella i saw you floating the possibility of marshal/mist w/w but i don’t think it’s likely

imo this is too chad of a post to make about marshal as partners. imagine reading someone’s wallpost scumcase on your partner and being like “actually it reminded me why i townread them” lmao. this is just one micro thing, but in the reverse direction, marshal’s read on mist feels too whiteknighty/in your face to be on a wolf partner especially when it’s being leveraged as a point against arete (marshal saying arete should be townreading mist by now) - that sort of thing is blatantly unpartnered since wolf!marshal’s arete case is the crutch of her play and she’d be careful not to invalidate it in this way

yeah thats entirely reasonable

[Illwei]

rokon
wisdom
Arctic
Wazza
Vulgard
Arete
Nutella
Alana

[Arctic]

@Kyubey

@Arctic can you elaborate on your hippo read

i had a bad gut reaction to hippo’s first content post being a consensus scumread on min but in hindsight it’s reasonable for village hippo to want to iso min after seeing the discussion about them and reaching the same conclusion
his read of marl powerwolfing felt massively misplaced and he never talked about it again, i don’t know if it was a joke or what but the lack of attachment just indicates it wasn’t real to begin with
the thing i liked the most from his slot is his reference to a past-game in which he townread wolf!wind for agreeing with her takes after realizing he was doing the same thing here, that kinda felt like a genuine flashback Moment TM
i’d actually probably have him somewhere nullscum-ish but the rest of the reasons boil down to a bad meta case of the fact he seems more reasonable/consensus-y than he normally is as town, which is probably quite a reductionist view
still think he’s been townread a bit too easily

[Arctic]

illwei why do you town read me i don’t think i’ve seen you actually talk about me in a post, i’ve just seen you high on your list every time you post it lmao

[Hippopablompoyeetus]

Same

[Hippopablompoyeetus]

I dont think ur a wolf sepxifcially with arete, ur just both wolfy and i remember u saying a post how u arent aligned and i dont think thats true

[min]

when was I consensus scumread lol

[Hippopablompoyeetus]

I havent seen a single squirrel post tbh

[Arctic]

@Marshal

Ideally I should be vigged, not doing so is antitown. If not I will fight to live but I won’t use emotional manipulation or make it all about me, if i’m obviously gonna die I will quietly leave a legacy and fuck off.

ftr I think it’s bad play not to kill me if arete flips town and vice versa, a basically lock wolfread from an extremely competent player should not be let live.

this post feels wrong
this feels like you are saying what a villager should be expected to think from the basic rules of mafia/wagons and that you’re being virtuous or stoic or something by sacrificing yourself when in reality i think a villager would have responded to this post by talking about how their worldview is changed in light of the flip

also the fact that you refer to yourself being a lock wolfread if arete flips town is just weh
you think it’s wolfy for you to be wrong? just feels like guilty conscience

[Hippopablompoyeetus]

@Moonwink

Why are you being so defensive of Min right now? :3 Are you two scum partners?

Was this a serious post because the quotes you gave dont show me defending min and i dont think i have all game?