Poor Approximations of Catgirls - Thread 1

[alana]

also @wisdom why can’t me and Marshal both be mafia if you scumread us both?

and why did you never mentioned the check on Marshal yet mentioned a check on me?

[alana]

this makes a lot of sense actually

[Arctic]

i am concerned by a couple things tho

like her asking wind why vulgard would buss marshal doesn’t really make sense in the context of her own marshal wolfread as well as the fact that when marshal asked her the same thing earlier she responded as though she could see it plausibly being a thing so idt this line of questioning really makes sense? idk

@Marshal

Why would he bus me and not a worse wolf player

@Mistyx

spew manipulation?
extra cred?
spite?

---

@WindwardAway

I explained earlier it’s because Vulgard knew he needed one wolf to die and guess him as LW to join the chat

Because he was informed, he would’ve picked at least one teammate to push. His hardest push was JC who flipped town, so imo he voteparked on Marshal hoping she’d flip. It’s a win-win for him regardless of flips because either a villager dies which benefits all wolves, or a wolf dies which benefits Vulgard for joining the chat.

@Mistyx

why do you think he’d push marshal over a different wolf with worse thread positioning

[min]

@WindwardAway

I refuse to believe it’s objectively bad to vote Marshal
But nobody is selling me on why she’s town
Just parroting everyone else by saying vaguely that her macro is good and Vulgard wouldn’t vote a partner is far from what I’d call convincing reasons
Convince me what she’s done that benefits town. Give specific examples. Make me believe that you guys actually believe what you’re saying instead of handwaving, because you can absolutely misclear a wolf and set them up to endgame this way, and I don’t want that to happen with any slots, including but not limited to Marshal.

@WindwardAway

Like seriously, if you guys continue to say voting Marshal is bad because Vulgard’s spew makes her town, it isn’t a stronger argument than how I’m saying I think she’s spewed wolf from Vulgard. It’s just two opposite interpretations meaning that it actually isn’t crystal clear.

If you’re going to argue back with a subjective interpretation and tell me my read is bad and wrong without giving examples, then vote me and I’ll thunderdome Marshal.

@WindwardAway

I’m not even completely set on locking marshal as a wolf but the arguments toward her being town have not been good arguments.

@WindwardAway

I like how basically nobody commented on this post despite people insisting Marshal is town for, idk, a while

idk if im overeading into things but

[Wisdom]

Lol that’s a cool role

I’ll buy it!

[Marluxion]

on one hand
jc is one of the most respected players on MU and he was obvious town

on the other hand, i have a slice of pizza so it’s hard to be upset

[min]

this feels like

super extra for someone who said “I haven’t locked marshal scum yet”

[Wazza]

@Marluxion

i’m trying to determine how mad i am about the jc shot

I had an option of 4 people, 2 of which I was never going to kill (You and Arctic) so it was Wind or JC
I made up my mind on Wind when I asked you guys for your reads, JC refused to engage, Arctic didn’t give me a good answer, Wind told me JC and you told me Wind.

[min]

wow

honestly yea I would not mind this dying

[Wisdom]

I’m less tilted than I was a few minutes ago. Spam vigging JC is way better than killing him instead of literally anyone in the consensus PoE.

[Marluxion]

@Wazza

JC refused to engage, Arctic didn’t give me a good answer, Wind told me JC and you told me Wind.

ok so why in the name of christ did you listen to wind instead of me

[Wazza]

I didn’t listen to Wind, I listened to you until JC voted last second to condemn Arete

[Arctic]

okay wow i need to read these posts

[Wisdom]

sorry to break it to you…
Although you DID just save a mash so I shouldn’t tease you!

[Marluxion]

TWO mashes! IN A ROW!

[Marluxion]

albeit scum dayvigged me so i couldn’t finish the job on AP in bastard mash and lolkatzeinnocentchildmafiagodfather

[Arctic]

this feels disingenuous

nobody thinks to withhold a scumread and wait until an appropriate time to interact with the player

[Wisdom]

Tbf I was getting there on AP/Katze as well until I got NK’d so we’re even on that one :3

But nonetheless
You’re great and should not be underestimated!

[Arctic]

i disagree what’s bad about it

[Marluxion]

ok i’m pocketed, time to exe windward