Popcorny Redux🍿- (GAME OVER, MAFIA VICTORY)

Forum Games Completed
,
#943

oh wow you responded to that so seriously
what they said was so silly I assumed it was a joke

#944

Yeah I thought it was a joke too so I liked it because when it comes to F5 we have to kinda just lay out all cards on the table for a solve.

#945

Hi everyone!
I’m most likely going to be shooting Madeline unless someone can convince me otherwise.

Their case on me was not good, simply put. It misrepresented both how I have played this game and boiled down to be being “too correct” this game to not be scum. I’ll take it as a compliment.

She’s also been constantly hedging on Bionic’s slot, constantly calling them a wolf and calling them scum but at the same time saying they shouldn’t be shot. I don’t like how they handled my slot at all there and I’m sad that Otter decided to shoot me because of it.

Right now, I think 2/3 wolves exist in Madeline/Kiiruma/Eliza.

I will shoot by 11:00 pm EST tonight. Make your case for your shot by then. If you townread Madeline, do something about it.

#946

I think Bionic is probably my top townread as well funnily enough, especially with how Madeline has handled their slot!

1 Like
#947

:wowee:

The crime of being wrong in a mafia game.

You went from top townreading me to saying you want to shoot me because I didn’t townread you and was wrong on your slot.

#948

I townread Madeline so please allow me to try and dissuade you from shooting there.

Early game I would’ve agreed on your read, as I felt like this post amongst some other early ones felt like Madeline was trying to be a people pleaser.

However, I did like Madeline’s thoughts concerning Achro and it felt somewhat unpaired. One of the best posts by Madeline was this in which Madeline analysed a potential take on the wolves’ game plan based on Achro.

Also considering how Luka hadn’t flipped yet, Madeline had another good take consider their slot which can be found here. I personally believe that Madeline’s early game was relatively decent, with some misreads (E.G. You)

I can move onto some later parts too, but I wanted to get this out so you at least start thinking about it.

I think killing Bionic and Eliza wins us the game. If not, then sure, Madeline’s a wolf. But I think Madeline is good(?). Being my 2nd most confident townread.

#949

You accused me the crime of being right, a crime which you had also committed. Your read doesn’t make any sense to me. I don’t see why you would want me shot over other players unless you realized I was going to re-eval you and you were scared I’d find you scum.

#950

That isn’t accurate. I had realized that I didn’t have a strong reason to townread any player, including you, and that I should re-eval you from your position at the top because you really didn’t’ deserve it. I didn’t make that clear at the time because I wanted to sleep.

#951

If you think the core part of the case is just that you were right, then skill issue.

#952

I really don’t like this part personally.
With Luka, with Treasure, you weren’t hedging on their reads at all. All you said was “They are a wolf.”

With Bionic and me, you keep saying that we could be town, but that we are a wolf. You are admitting that you’re wrong before they ever flip. I personally think Bionic is threadspewed town but you keep insisting that they’re wolf, and that they shouldn’t be shot. You realize we win if we shoot the wolves right?

#953

K

You’re wrong though

I literally do not care to explain myself to you, it sounds exhausting and I personally think you’re too lost to OMGUS to ever be persuaded anyway

Im fine with being the gun holder in F5 and then you can think about maybe not OMGUSing so hard in the future

#954

That’s disappointing.

I was egging you on honestly. i wasn’t sold on a shot on you. I wanted to see how you responded.
You haven’t even made it clear who you want shot. Present your reads for me please.

#955

I did not town read you at any point in time
At best I was pretty meh on your slot. That’s definitely a skill issue from me since you’re town.

But you treating someone who was formerly your top town read as outed wolf when she’s the one that made the case that got two wolves killed for advocating to shoot you when she’s been meh on you all game and then thought she had a similar catch as with treasure and Luka

It’s very skill issue on your part, I am town and have the right to be salty at someone losing their shit over being scum read

#956

I town read kiiruma for aforementioned reasons

Bionic is most likely to be wolf just off of “head empty, no reads” wolf archetype read but I also have complete confidence in them losing us the game if they’re town, and like, there are also “head empty, no reads” town archetype players too, so in that way it’s a risky shot. Idc if you call it hedgy, I’m not pretending like I have confidence on a slot that’s barely playing.

The rest are a bucket of nulls that I’m not going to pretend to have a bunch of super insightful reads on

I really wish jail had elaborated on their town read on Eliza too because wow I do not understand what they saw with that slot.

1 Like
#957

@Kiiruma If I shot you who would you shoot?
@ElizaThePsycho If I shot you who would you shoot?

#958

probably bionic…?
but i wouldn’t have a good shot for them to take like they request so

#959

Why would you shoot Bionic?

#960

well
they seem to be ~consensus poe
and i have cleared Kii based on Luka iso
so that makes a poe of
…oh

#961

Who do you think Bionic is teamed with?

#962

i see