Popcorny Redux🍿- (GAME OVER, MAFIA VICTORY)

[Badeline]

Ah, I wouldn’t recognize it then.

[Badeline]

@otterpopd

i have refused to read madeline and badeline so far because celeste is a good game and I have opinions about it that I don’t want to confuse with their slot alignments.

I’ll townread otter for this alone. Their reads leave something to be desired, but I relate heavily with this staement.

[Badeline]

@Madeline

The whole back and forth with Achro superficially felt unaligning, but if the goal was to specifically distance with his teammates, then I could see worlds where Achro and you did that whole thing as w/w theater.

I want to look back on those arguments specifically as well. Luka had a very similar wolf theater argument with Achro that I could easily see Achro directing from scumchat. I’d even say the more arguments a player had with Achro, the more likely they are to be scum. We can tell from Luka’s flip that distancing heavily from Achro was the plan wolves had. It’s best to look at those players following that plan and make sure they don’t live long.

[Badeline]

@Leafia

Since I doubt anyone else will be doing it, I’ll now iso myself to determine if I’m a villager or a wolf.

Wolfy self meta. Leafia should shoot here.

[Badeline]

@Kiiruma

Towards the end of the ISO there was something which felt very fake. Interactions with Tutuu started off with questions on Achro’s part. This post in itself shows that Achro was less so wanting to produce content by themselves and instead wanted to get others to say some things, to point out later. I don’t really know what it says about Tutuu/Achro fully because it’s just weird, I’d be keeping an eye there potentially.

Lack of TMI about the Tutuu kill. Could easily be faked but it’s a rarity to see Kiiruma not TMIing info. Post itself also likely had a lot of work put into it. I’ll give Kiiruma a townlean for now, even if I think their opening wasn’t great.

[Badeline]

Looks like I’ve caught up all the way!

The other Part of Me seems to be town. I’d also say that Kiiruma, Otter, and Eliza have some things going for them. None of them hold a solid part in my head though as opposed to the other Part of Me.

I’d like to see more from Bionic and Guava as they both haven’t posted much. I think the way Kiiruma analyzed Achro poitns to Jail being mafia as well.

I need to take another look at Treasure’s slot but I have them at a scumlean because of their interactions with Achro.

Is there anybody else in thread right now who would like to discuss these slots?

[jail]

LOL leafia youre goated

[Kiiruma]

@Badeline

I think the way Kiiruma analyzed Achro poitns to Jail being mafia as well.

It’s entirely possible Achro has had some amount of antispew. After all, the slot asked to be shot, so anything they said could be a toss up or social play, so I don’t think Jail has to be mafia. I just think there’s a higher chance of that being true.

[jail]

@Badeline

think the way Kiiruma analyzed Achro poitns to Jail being mafia as well.

naw there is no way. i swear i could literally rand inno child and someone would wolfread me read like all of my iso atp

anyway luka being mafia is epic but like what is this wolfteam doing ? iirc i saw luka telling leafia to shoot them and achros was quickly shot like ?? you cannot tell me the entire wolfteam is gonna sink this way

[jail]

ok i am like freezing. thats crazy

[Leafia]

@guavagudetama

Why even backread anymore it’s popcorn I can just livepost and if I get shot it doesn’t matter cuz I live anyway

Guava probably town.

@Treasure

If you don’t read what happened previously and only look on the future, a killer can change their behaviour to look better for you so you don’t shoot them.

Only important if you have the gun, but best to backread just in case you get it.

@Badeline

Hi everyone, I’ve been fairly busy today but I’m here now! I’m catching up currently and will post my full thoughts in a bit. I’m surprised to see that Tutuu was the revenge kill, but now that I can also see Luka was a mafia player I think there’s a very good chance Madeline is actually town. If I remember correctly, I was skimming some posts earlier and she posted a very solid case against Luka. I may be misremembering though. Anyhow, back to catching up!

Hi. Mindmeld here too. Madeline likely town.

@otterpopd

i read luka as town. we are now 2 for 2 on people who asked to get shot getting shot and flipping wolf. EXTREMELY funny

Laughs True.

@Badeline

I want to look back on those arguments specifically as well. Luka had a very similar wolf theater argument with Achro that I could easily see Achro directing from scumchat. I’d even say the more arguments a player had with Achro, the more likely they are to be scum. We can tell from Luka’s flip that distancing heavily from Achro was the plan wolves had. It’s best to look at those players following that plan and make sure they don’t live long.

If looking very heavily paired by pushing the same wolfy agenda as your scumbuddy is your definition of unpairing, more power to you. Giggles It’s honestly why I shot him. He looked super paired up with Achro to me due to his push on Eliza. Which Achro also did.

At this point in time, I’d say Eliza being a wolf is extremely unlikely, although not impossible.

@Badeline

Wolfy self meta. Leafia should shoot here.

Agreed. Shoots self

Leafia has died.
Leafia has flipped wolf.
The gun now goes to Ghost Leafia.

@Badeline

I’d like to see more from Bionic and Guava as they both haven’t posted much. I think the way Kiiruma analyzed Achro poitns to Jail being mafia as well.

I can see Jail potentally being a wolf here. Might be my next shot. Not 100% certain though.

@Badeline

Is there anybody else in thread right now who would like to discuss these slots?

How about Treasure’s slot? Can you explain your wolfread on them?

@jail

LOL leafia youre goated

True. This flattery does seem a bit wolfy but it’s appreciated at the same time.

@Kiiruma

It’s entirely possible Achro has had some amount of antispew. After all, the slot asked to be shot, so anything they said could be a toss up or social play, so I don’t think Jail has to be mafia. I just think there’s a higher chance of that being true.

This is fair enough.

@jail

ok i am like freezing. thats crazy

I hope you can get warmed up soon then.

[Leafia]

I also won’t be shooting any more tonight. I had a hard enough time sleeping last night after that wolf flip and Luka’s flip is showing me that at least a bad dream I had last night isn’t going to come true. In said dream, this game was going on, but I always had the gun and couldn’t die and after shooting Achro, I shot again 5 more times, killing 5 villagers in the process.

[Treasure]

@otterpopd

does anyone else want to ask to get shot

I don’t oppose.
It’ll be the first time an Innocent would be shot.
Although I wouldn’t want to ruin leaf’s streak, she is on a roll.

[Leafia]

I’d rather shoot the next wolf tomorrow. Any wolves want to volunteer?

[Leafia]

True. I am.

[Treasure]

@Badeline

their argument with Achro

I feel like I had more of an argument with Achro but ok.

[Leafia]

@Treasure

I don’t oppose.
It’ll be the first time an Innocent would be shot.
Although I wouldn’t want to ruin leaf’s streak, she is on a roll.

We have a volunteer it seems.

[Treasure]

@Badeline

I need to take another look at Treasure’s slot but I have them at a scumlean because of their interactions with Achro.

I could have sworn you read me as innocent before.

[Leafia]

Not going to lie though, but Treasure is seeming a bit villagery right now.

[Treasure]

Maybe that was just TuTuu and Luka but I thought you agreed too.