Publicly Reviewed Roles Thread

Game Discussion
#141

Question for Eli
does it count as a win if you die early and are revived into final 4?

1 Like
#142

me when I’m town and I randomly resurrect the Neutral Killer in final 3

3 Likes
#143

I can’t stay for much longer.
But

I want to hear you say
 “I love you.”
Serial Killer-senpai


It must be done.




If it helps you
 forget all of this happened. Hearing the sound of your voice





I


I love you, Serial Killer-senpai.

1 Like
#144

It’s okay it happens to the best of us

2 Likes
#145

((in case you were curious, this was post was a copy-pasted part of a decisive gambit I took, a crucial part of which was rp’ing as a tsundere
((hope that answers any questions you might have

2 Likes
#146


 one last question

why

1 Like
#147

as in

“you revive when there’s 4 players alive excluding you”
or
“you revive when there’s 4 players alive including the just-revived-you”
either way “probably”

1 Like
#148

the latter
the former you still probably win but its not like, game gets called immediately
you win as soon as anybody but you dies tho

fun fact:
that was also the game where I had the role that post-restricted people into saying “nya” in every post

1 Like
#149

No you cant

1 Like
#150

:star: :star:

Rating 2/5

Reason:
It really is just a buffed serial killer, so like yeah it’s a buffed serial killer. Not really that creative, and the bonus cookies are = rand so that’s fun too. It prolly is a fun role, as you aren’t directly harming people but it might be a bit game breaking in f5 where you could just out yourself and have everyone win. I guess that’s the main problem, you can out yourself and everyone wins, so there doesn’t need to be the cookie win thingy.

Lore:
ME LIKE COOKIE, C IS FOR COOKIE COOKIE IS FOR ME. Shouted the the fluffy blue monster. Crack, Crack, Crack. The door began to be pounded in, the home owners quivered in fear as they countinoud to hear the blue mosnter repeat the same 2 lines “C IS FOR COOKIE, COOKIE IS FOR ME”. FInally, crash, the door caved in and the gigantic blue monster rushed into the building. “NO PLEASE DON’T-” it was too late, the cookie monster had already taken a bite out of the man. “COOKIE IS TASTY” said the Cookie Monster.

2 Likes
#151

:star: :star:

Rating:
2/5

Reason:
I don’t really like roles that make mafia play a certain way, like this role is an intended bus which = jester role. I don’t think that a mafia role like this should only have one way that they can play their role. Like every setup with this role involves this role dying first for mafia.

Lore:
I’ll do it later

#152

I think its a solo win, not a group one

1 Like
#153

this

I guess you can’t all win, as half of the player’s aren’t cookies

#154

Oh thats stupid I didn’t see that

1 Like
#155

Unlike the Serial Killer, the Cookie Monster can die during Night Phase. Cookies are always town, and since only the Cookies can win if they were eaten by the Cookie Monster, anyone else would lose. That would the the incentives for the normal Town and the Mafia to kill the Cookie Monster.

#156
Extra Story

Funny that you mentioned that, because that role never died.
–I never died in SCP FM.
It is a nice backup in case I was raising Town’s suspicions, but fortunately the we killed the Neutrals / Neutral Killings before they could kill us, and Town was just happy collateral damage.

#157

:star: :star2:

Rating: 1.5/5

Reason: Seems really good based on the setup as if town has one mislynch you can force MyLo.

1 Like
#158

Schrödinger’s Sorcerer

Town Killer

Phenomenal Cosmic Powers (Night) - Target a player. They will become a Compulsive Suicide Bomber. Privately, they must choose a player to detonate upon by the end of the day or their target will be randomized amongst all alive players other than themselves. The detonation has several possible outcomes, all with equal weight. There is no way to determine the result other than by investigating the player during the day.

  • The player and their target will die
  • The player will die but not the target
  • The target will die but not the player
  • Neither the player nor the target will die
3 Likes
#159

the return of the king

2 Likes
#160

Can’t everyone just win with order 66 + rule of two

2 Likes