Yes
1 Like
Another thing I am worried about: In this set-up, it’s very easy to fake inactive to get voted up. I understand our intentions of keeping active townie people in to solve, but a wolf who is being falsely town-cleared can easily fly under the radar utilizing this strategy of ours against us. With that being said, we are more unanimous on our Eq townread than Eliza (that I know of). I think it’s best we vote there imo
1 Like
As I mentioned, I suspect pigeon hard-distanced from their teammates. With that being said, let’s look at who they talked about and/or interacted with.
Early vote on Bionic. I suspect it’s likely they’re not aligned.
Casting suspicion onto Eliza. They’re also probably not aligned.
This is to show he interacted with townies.
I believe this was the first Heaven phase vote. I questioned them on why they wanted to beam up Lol over Caitlin, and this was the response I got. I suspect Lol may be scum who pigeon didn’t want to link up with.
Interacting with Rawkhawk. I don’t take this as pigeon defending Rawkhawk rather as them trying to appear townie trying to solve. I don’t think they suspected they’d be pushed at this point.
Pigeon interacting with me.
Votes Hawk out of self-preservation, but it was far too late given the results. It’s possible the vote was used to mask a scum (voting for them to hide it), but I think it’s unlikely. Let’s look at the votes:
thepigeonnyc (7): Achromatic, Mimic, RawkHawk, ElizaThePsycho, PrincessPeach, CaptainSyrup, PrincessDaisy
RawkHawk (3): Bionic, otterpopd, thepigeonnyc
CaptainSyrup (1): lol
By the time pigeon voted, it was apparent they’d be voted out. I can’t say for certain whether the pushback clears Rawk or not.
@PrincessPeach I know you were curious about the results of my backread, so I’m pinging you with what I noted.
I’m not saying we should push Lol in the next Hell phase. I’m more so putting my thoughts out there, and then we can work with what we know
1 Like
Oh sorry that was a bigger post than I thought
One thing to address first: I think Achro or someone else said that Abigail defends their teammates:
Potential Examples of Defending Teammates
quote=“PrincessAbigail, post:309, topic:6856, full:true”]
She’s town bet
[/quote]
Reviewing Votes:
Hell Phase 1
dangerouslitter (5): Bionic, ElizaThePsycho, thepigeonnyc, Caitlin, PrincessAbigail
Bionic (3): dangerouslitter, CaptainSyrup, RawkHawk
RawkHawk (1): lol
ElizaThePsycho (1): Achromatic
Mimic (1): Toad
thepigeonnyc (1): otterpopd
Not Voting (3): PrincessPeach, PrincessDaisy, Mimic
Scum really wanted Litten out, but would they have the team comp that would be willing to dogpile to force it out?
Thanks to Toad, this is the results of the swing-swing swing onto Caitlin that I started:
This was the final vote for Abigail’s exe:
PrincessAbigail (4): Caitlin, lol, otterpopd, dangerouslitter
Caitlin (4): CaptainSyrup, Bionic, RawkHawk, PrincessAbigail
dangerouslitter (2): ElizaThePsycho, thepigeonnyc
thepigeonnyc (1): Toad
ElizaThePsycho (1): Achromatic
unvote (1): PrincessDaisy
Not Voting (2): PrincessPeach, Mimic
Heaven Phase 1
This vote was early on in Heaven Phase when we were discussing a candidate. There was this abnormal push for Lol to be voted to Heaven.
Caitlin (6): PrincessPeach, CaptainSyrup, PrincessDaisy, Mimic, RawkHawk, Bionic
lol (4): Caitlin, otterpopd, thepigeonnyc, lol
dangerouslitter (3): Achromatic, dangerouslitter, ElizaThePsycho
Not Voting (1): Toad
Upon reviewing the first Heaven phase vote, it does seem interesting that pigeon wanted Lol to get into Heaven over the almost universally townread Caitlin/Eq. And keep in mind, they refused to elaborate on why. If Lol does flip mafia, my immediate suspicion falls onto otterpopd. Yes, I know someone said they had good reads across the board, but it’s easy to have good reads when you know the board. I can’t say for certain I trust it
These were the votes pretty much right before the CFD onto Pigeon:
Votecount as of post #2048
CaptainSyrup (4): Toad, RawkHawk, lol, PrincessPeach
RawkHawk (4): Bionic, CaptainSyrup, otterpopd, ElizaThePsycho
thepigeonnyc (1): Achromatic
ElizaThePsycho (1): Mimic
Not Voting (3): EqsyLootz, PrincessDaisy, thepigeonnyc
Keep in mind that Achro was the first one to push onto Pigeon. Then, they were shortly followed by Toad and Story/Mimic. It could be a bus attempt. Not sure yet. Regardless, it’s something to keep track of.
Vote Count for Pigeon’s exe:
thepigeonnyc (7): Achromatic, Mimic, RawkHawk, ElizaThePsycho, PrincessPeach, CaptainSyrup, PrincessDaisy
RawkHawk (3): Bionic, otterpopd, thepigeonnyc
CaptainSyrup (1): lol
Not Voting (2): EqsyLootz, Toad
Stuff to note: I was hammer for this vote, and Syrup was the second to last to vote here (when it was clear Pigeon was going over). It may not mean anything, but again, something to keep in mind.
I won’t cover Heaven Phase 2 yet since that has yet to be complete, but yeee this should bring us up to speed. I was tempted to do a similar style posts with everyone’s reads and how they evolved but holy heck that’s a lot of work. I’m gonna take a break lol
As mentioned, I’m going to be taking a break away from thread. In that time, I’d advise against beaming me up to Heaven. Given our low activity rate, I want to be here to push us in the right direction and encourage solving. I know it is not the best to advocate against beaming myself up, but given threadstate, I think that’s best. (As it currently stands, I am not a Heaven candidate, but I’ve seen some scary swings this game lol)
Off topic but have a Happy News Years everyone! I think after this day ends, we go on break. I hope you all have a wonderful evening! :D
I said she tends to defend town, actually.
1 Like
EqsyLootz (4): CaptainSyrup, otterpopd, PrincessPeach, lol
ElizaThePsycho (2): Achromatic, ElizaThePsycho
Toad (1): RawkHawk
EqsyLoots (1): Bionic
Not Voting (4): EqsyLootz, PrincessDaisy, Mimic, Toad
This is fine tbh
busy new years stuff yesterday and later today so fine wih slow from me today.
Will just yeet a wolf tomorrow to win the game
Everyone enjoy their new years!
@EqsyLootz has been sent to Heaven.
They were...
Hobbes, Vanilla Town
Win Condition: You win when majority of the Mafia is sent to Hell. You lose when majority of the Mafia is sent to Heaven.
1 Like
Hell Phase 3 begins now. It ends in 24 hours. Gar will have the time up shortly. 
Hello everyone
@otterpopd
@CaptainSyrup
@PrincessPeach
@ElizaThePsycho
@PrincessDaisy
@Mimic
@Bionic
@Achromatic
@Toad
@RawkHawk
@lol
Hello! 
Also, oops sorry misremembered