Silent Hill Newbie Friendly JOAT 10er 4/10 Day 3 - Mafia Wins

Forum Games Completed
,
#881

wrong answer

#882

what would you do if someone you pushed flipped town?

#883

prob move on
imma be real I think I was typing “wrong answer” no matter what u said

1 Like
#884

this is literally the definition of bad faith

#885

fair enough yeah

#886

@Drinks if you’re still here, any thoughts on everything we’ve said here? iirc you had us both as town last read list

#887

What I don’t understand is why you found what Ranta did so scummy, especially when I’ve been pushing you far far harder

#888

I can see this as town cannibalism or that you (evil) are pushing something aggressively that YBW (good) is saying isn’t a fair push. It’s particularly odd for me to chime in since I think Ranta isn’t really a suspect by low posts but that’s largely by benefit of doubt, so my reason for thinking your push on Ranta is bad is slightly different than YBW.
So basically tl;dr my view says this is YBW(Good) + Ranta (Good) v Kanave (Evil) or YBW (Good) + Ranta (???) v Kanave (Cannibal Good), YBW thinks it’s more likely the former of the two from the conversaion as I read it and while I trust her, it’s not enough of a credit to pile onto you.

#889

Its not like Im certain they’re scum, im just more certain than the alternatives. Drinks and Plague both have some weird posts and bad arguements but I can see them coming from a good player. With Ranta, she not only doesn’t have the new player excuse, but also doesn’t have the good posts to contrast it to.

#890

You mainly seem to find their push on you scummy, and their lack of posts

Lack of posts is NAI personally, but I wanna know why you find their push scummy but not mine

#891

And push is in like, massive quotes there

#892

I read you as good earlier in the day, esp for the demi townsheild which i even at the time basically was wanting to call demi good but wasn’t confident enough to do. You push on me here seems to be based on the pretense that you don’t think my arguement on Ranta was good. Even if a disagree the foundation your posts are built on isn’t inheriently scummy, where as Ranta’s reading of my posts is just bad

#893

yeah ok fine

/unvote

ill stop being tunneled for now
i looked at stuff again and while I think the beginning of ur push was messy, it can come from town, and your focus on defending your push and what you said rather tahn defending yourself seems p good to me. Even though me and eliza had voted you, you still cared more about getting Ranta out which seems V. I’ll find someone else to tunnel on in a bit dont worry

#894

@Host_Account_1 can we have a vote count

#895
Vote Target Voted by Votes
Kanave Eliza, Plague, 2
Drinks guava 2
Ranta Kanave 1
guava Drinks 1
Plague Jaiden 1
Not Voting Ranta, Sadbi, Demisha, YoubutWorse 3
1 Like
#896

JOAT 10er Day 1 - Votecount 6

Vote Target Voted by Votes
Kanave Eliza, Plague 2
Drinks guava 1
Ranta Kanave 1
guava Drinks 1
Plague Jaiden 1
Not Voting Ranta, Sadbi, Demisha, YoubutWorse 4

Reminder to ping this account for votes and/or any mistakes.

Reminder EoD is at 2022-07-04T18:00:00Z

1 Like
#897

I won this time :3
even if there was a typo in the not voting collum

#898

sorry hosts I keep forgetting to ping lmao

#899

They’re trying to make us feel guilty

1 Like
#900

YBW, I take it you still don’t want to vote Ranta, who do you want to vote today