Silent Hill Newbie Friendly JOAT 10er 4/10 Day 3 - Mafia Wins

well thats helpful

1 Like

JOAT 10er Day 1 - Votecount 8

Vote Target Voted by Votes
Kanave Eliza, Plague 2
Sadbi YoubutWorse 1
Drinks guava 1
Ranta Kanave 1
guava Drinks 1
Plague Jaiden 1
Not Voting Ranta, Sadbi, Demisha 3

Reminder to ping this account for votes and/or any mistakes.

Reminder EoD is at 2022-07-04T18:00:00Z

Hi guys, this vote is bad who else do we want to exe :upside_down_face:

PlagueSimp or Demisha for me

Drinks Plague Demi is my list

*ranta not demi

Iā€™m 2/3 in agreement

is anyone else on?

also wtf drinks is here

1 Like

fake pster

readlist bc eh

Town
Me :DDDDD

Demi - From what Iā€™ve seen of them, especially their opener, they are just town. Compare how they palyed in this to how they played in FAM and I hope youā€™ll see exactly what I mean. I can explain in further detail if really really needed but tbh i think its kinda obvi

Townlean
Jaiden - I havenā€™t ISOd them, but every interaction with them just feels good and like they believe what theyā€™re saying. I remember (drinks I believe?) mentioning that they just seem like an aggressive town and I agreed with that.

Eliza - tbh her apathy sounds genuine and I think she actually managed to read thread, see stuff happen, and then have no thoughts. Has happened tome before

Drinks - Everyone is piling on them for like, no reason tbh. The maina rgument is that theyā€™ve only been ā€œfluff postingā€ but they really havenā€™t? Also if were talking about fluff posting we should be looking at sadbi or plague lmao. Donā€™t really understand the push on them, they seem to believe what theyā€™re saying

Neutral
Ranta - Has barely posted, honestly kinda see them as town mainly bc like no one besides me was even trying to defend them. Nothing to read by itself tho

Kanave - Iā€™m done tunneling them and while I do wanna townread them, their read on Ranta is still v weird to me, but it sounds like they believe it. I forgot who else mentioned that they usually donā€™t conf bias which might be important since I think thatā€™s applicable in that read, will probably come back to later (esp if around in LYLO)

Scumlean
Plague - Havenā€™t done much and it doesnā€™t seem like they have a ton of thoughts of their own. When I asked them to change their vote onto Kanave and they just did, I found it kinda weird and still do. Keep eyes on this slot.

Guava - Literally no one has thoughts on guava for some reason despite them not having a ton of great posts. ALso their ISO on drinks just feels kinda shady, and their ISO on sadbi feels kinda lazy considering Sadbi has given like 1 readlist and that had all of their reads. Iā€™m just not a big fan of how Guava is handling other slots

Sadbi - Despite having like 40 posts, a decent amount are fluff. Also I donā€™t really like #622 at all. As Iā€™ve mentioned before (i think), both ISOā€™s feel agenda-y. Also they have a lot of townreads which isnā€™t evil by itself, but usually itā€™s easier for a scum to make townreads compared to scumreads. Also, little to no progression on Drinks. They end with Drinks in their scumlean, yet used to townread them. Their only progression on drinks is ā€œdrinks town council stocks dippingā€

now CAN PEOPLE PLS GIVE THEIR THOUGHTS ON GUAVA OR SADBI ESP SADBI BC I WOULD LIKE THEM TO BE TODAYS EXE

2 Likes

im shielding demi theyā€™re not a choice

let me iso Guava

i can settle for plague tbh

:shrimp:
I didnā€™t sleep

1 Like

wonder what spec chats sayin rn

2 Likes

After a long night sleep and reading what was posted overnight I still feel fairly confident on the vote preferences I had over night (ranta/eliza/drinks) but especially

This post I didnā€™t like. It accentuates my thoughts of her having played this entire game passively and struggling not only to have any town reads/leans but also (which this to me is a bit more worrying) to come up with more than 1 or 2 (if 2 one of them was retracted im pretty sure) wolf reads/leans.

I do agree with YBW that this could just be a town thatā€™s simply struggling to find anything because from the perspective of a wolf they would be actively and repeatedly trying to sleepwalk town into a ML vote and she hasnā€™t been doing that so iā€™ll just keep her in my watch list I wouldnā€™t wanna vote her today.

If weā€™re going by this sleepwalk town into ML vote logic then guava would fit a lot with a few subtle different pushes heā€™s made but im not very confident in this vote, heā€™s also heavy townread me multiple times which could be subtle pocketing but again im not sure because I feel the points they brought up for that are more or less reasonable.

I think YBWā€™s point of Sadbiā€™s ISOing being very agenda-looking the way they concluded their thoughts is valid and im inclined to vote that.

Kanave and Drinks im not too solid on either side to be able to decide whether I wanna vote them or not

1 Like

Yeah no I just finished ISOing Eliza and im confident to say this is a town that doesnā€™t give a lot of reads is all
There is a lot of fluff but looking at the game she linked she plays like that and thereā€™s a decent chunk of posts that arenā€™t trivial but the main thing that makes me feel safe about her is that she hasnā€™t been driving sleepwalky ML votes at all

Before I forget
/vote sadbi
@Host_Account_1