Don’t remember if I answered this earlier btw
I don’t really disagree with it anymore, I’ve looped around to thinking Caitlin might be town
But at the time, I disagreed purely because I thought Caitlin’s posts were scummy.
VOTE: Garfooled
I don’t have a good track record of reading Garfooled but I am going off Abbi’s theory and think that Garfooled is more likely to be scum than Caitlin.
Since you guys keep asking me for vote explanations.
Also, does Garfooled usually hold onto their reads for long? Like do they make reads and not move them around too much, or does their readlist shift a lot when they’re town and solving? Because Caitlin has been Garfooled’s primary push all day and they’re the only one still voting her.
My hot take is a wolf in Luka/May/Arctic. There is a curious trend in my D1 reads where my gut is right on a wolf and completely wrong on another.
Intresting why?
You think she won’t mason with you even if she’s TR-ing you? Why tho?
She’s anti masonry she won’t do it period and I’m well aware of that
So I ask her to troll mainly lol.
Humor me on this, but can you share at least one thing (behaviour, action, something they said, etc) about each of these people that bothered you/you didn’t like/you didn’t understand?
Every person in this entire game?
psure they meat the people you put in your town core
meat
*meant
I didn’t think you were scummy to begin with, actually, but I was considering that Abbi was likely right about the votes on Caitlin. That if Caitlin isn’t scum, one of the three voters could be. And I’m pretty sure Arctic is town, so that left Garfooled and you. I explained my read on Garfooled earlier but I withheld my read on you and moved my vote there as a subtle indication that I was considering Abbi’s theory and also reevaluating you.
TBH I want my tell to be right but I’m struggling to see a wolf in those 4 at all
Okay, after double-checking Cait’s towngame in Mountainous Arson, I feel confident that she’s town. I’ve observed that she’s more of a “wolfhunter” than a “townhunter”, and she tends to comment on how so-and-so/xyz post is sus esp during D1.
The way she reacts to Arctic & Luka in #391, #674, #677 — shoots back but doesn’t overexplain — feels as if she’s standing on solid ground (and not shifty/slimy in a way a wolf subconsciously does while finding their footing to gain better thread position/look better).
“Psyx, what do you mean by shift/slimy and how can you tell?” you might ask.
Well, if what Abbi mentioned earlier is correct, then Cait is the same type of player as me: someone who dislikes wolfing and prefers to play as vanilla townie.
This type of player tends to be super confident as town, but struggle to display the same boldness as wolf because they’re keenly aware that they’re “guilty”. Hence, these feelings of “guilt” are manifested when they are sussed — they try to “convince” the other person in a way where they’re actually trying to convince themselves.
I’m not picking up any of this in Cait’s ISO. Here she’s just blunt/snarky, brushes off the other person (in a “are-you-for-real” kind of way), and is more concerned about the other person than she is about herself/how people are seeing her.
I also like how she doesn’t seem to be hung-up on the people sussing her. I think wolf!Cait would ISO Arctic or Luka to get more ammunition/shield against them, instead of continuing making reads and commenting on other non-Abbi people.
Intresting why?
They’re the three most widely townread people from what I see.
Every person in this entire game?
Nono, just those 6 people in your towncore.
Psyx medium town for this
unless she’s making the whole thing up (which I doubt), she very much fit in her town confidence when I was pushing her
Two very important questions
A: What is medium town comapred to anything else
B: What is the meaning of life
my tiers are:
locktown
strong town
medium town
lean town
light town
slightly lower tr than May and you
oh my tiers are
Town
Lean town
Im replying to this message since ths is around where I left off iirc
If i missed anything then oh well
I don’t see this, what about it feels genuine to you?
Dont know, I think openings are mostly based on vibes. They do genuinly feel excited to rand town, and I would too after a few wolf flips in a row. If I did get wolf opening would probably feel dis-ingenuine
(keeping this in to remind myself so I don’t tunnelvision)
Townie, dont think a wolf would say thos. Woof woof.
Could you elaborate on this?
being a wolf, I had to just imitate what I’d always been doing
Why didn’t you want to mason Caitlin this game?
Abbi never said this. Im fairly certain they always want to mason cait.
Do you think Luka is the type to stay consistent as scum?
(I am the type. Obviously not the best of my self meta but Abbis seen my scum games, everything is methodical and organized. This is self meta tho so dont trust it to much.
I’ll keep this in mind as I keep reading as well, this entire post actually
Town but fakable.
Does this seem overly self-aware?
More seems needless. Dont know what it adds. I missed this statement all together; nice pointing it out <3.
Man… Unless Caitlin and Abigail are partnered, Abigail is proving to be towny as heck
They are never paired here. I refuse.
It’s not even that though
It’s a joke
Town; dont think wolf would correct me here. Once again fakable tho.
Would you consider that natural progression or faking it?
Depends. Not sure what exactly the reads are.
I would say the more votes I get, the less I would feel motivated to read back and progress in the game
Kinda wolfy post? Generally detering votes from them by threatening to not try. Despite this though, it feels genuine here? I dont know how a post can be both wolfy and towny but garfooled manages it.
Town can hedge too but they do it much less often cause they don’t care.
can I know what hedging means btw