I don’t see this, what about it feels genuine to you?
Despite that, early game comprehension of what’s going on and progressing the game with a gamestate + pointng things out that nobodys pointied out(that I agree with) is townie. Town lean on May’s slot.
I’ll keep this in mind as I read along
(keeping this in to remind myself so I don’t tunnelvision)
She openly said at the start of her post that she cant do things differently as wolf as thatl get her scum read or something similar; overall id say it leans good were this to be true.
Could you elaborate on this?
She is very indignant and pushy and not unwilling to let bias show and it’s towny. She moves so energetically. It’s towny.
What is she like as a wolf?
Is it visibly different?
This is a lot of words to say something that could’ve been said in like one sentence and it’s… very hedgy.
What is the issue about hedging?
Do you think Arctic is hedging because they’re hesitant to make an enemy of May?
Does this feel like T/W to you?
Well I also know Cait will never mason with me. She hates me obvs.
Why didn’t you want to mason Caitlin this game?
They seem to be your TR at this point I believe (post#190)
Scum are more wary of these inconsistencies town make them all the time
Do you think Luka is the type to stay consistent as scum?
Town Cait is all business. She likes towning especially when she’s not PR. She, like me, feels a strong desire to prove how good she is. She gets right down to it she pushes EVERYTHING she pulls the game out of RVS as quickly as possible she will grasp onto things early that others wouldn’t.
I’ll keep this in mind as I keep reading as well, this entire post actually
Orr town could not collectively skill issue on an obvious town just because she wanted to play mafia and pushed something and could instead kill someone who’s actually wolfy
Man… Unless Caitlin and Abigail are partnered, Abigail is proving to be towny as heck
but setup says we only have two scum in the game
Does this seem overly self-aware?
And could I ask what you would normally hate about that post @Windward
I think if I get your thought process on this, I could read into you better
I’m confused on how Gar moved up so quickly
Nothing they’ve said has been particularly townie to me
Strange hyper fixation on me all of the sudden, I don’t know what that especially means
I remember Creature doing the same to me in… I forget the game, maybe Need for Speed?
They turned out to be town
I’ll have to read more tbh, but they were also shooting me every day in that one scum game lol
IMO I’m an easy enemy to make
I don’t pushback when I’m pressured
Not especially well
I didn’t do well in the game they shot me 3x in
So I do feel uneasy about their push on me this game
I will flip town
It ain’t me fam squad
I’m alive bcus it’d be neat to get me out in final 5
My final defense of self in Wild West
Yeah I felt hopeless in catchup and motivation
Abigail feels too eager to TR people atm if that makes sense
If she were scum, she could just put her scumbuddy in this towncore and then use the towncore as an excuse to execute a bunch of townies because they aren’t in the towncore
Do you believe they are partnered with May for this?
Where does this leave me if you believe they are S/S all of the sudden?
I’m keeping Abbi’s read on Caitlin in mind, it’s at least worth considering even if I disagree with it
What do you feel you disagree about it?
Unexplained Caitlin vote other than quoting a post that doesn’t look like a bad post imo
You could have asked for an explanation, instead you just SR me for it and leave it at that
It was mostly the first thing that popped into my mind that I found weird
Because looking into Zug’s post on a surface level I just thought “oh they probably don’t believe they’ll get NK’d”
And it looked to me that Caitlin was actively looking for something to scum read someone on nothing to look like they’re a pushy towny
Again I haven’t seen Caitlin’s full response to pressure yet
And I am taking Abigail’s post into account for future posts
(Also again I did not see Arctic’s vote, tbh I was catching up and when I saw their vote I said “weird/funny coincidence”)
That’s… kind of outrageous, isn’t it?
I feel like it’s much more likely that, regardless of her alignment, she just didn’t understand that it was a joke
That’s for me to decide tbh be honest
After I see Caitlin’s response
But again you’re doing that thing where you’re defending for others
Which yes I should’ve expected that from you
That might actually be something you did as town, I don’t remember if you did it as scum
What are your thoughts on Abigail?
Did I really not answer this?
Man I was really RUSSIAN to respond wasn’t I?
(this pun works because I’m 1/4th Russian and was born there, don’t take this away from me!)
And not fully reading responses at all!
My thoughts on Abigail, I’ve never played with them as scum
But I am missing the sipping cup jiffs
And they aren’t much different as usual as they are when they are town
Which is confident and makes the right call endgame
And not you not wanting me to ISO you…?
I was being silly
I was being a goof and a gaff
This is kinda TWTBAW, in the sense that I dont think a wolf would openly admit not wanting to be ISOd.
It’s not even that though
It’s a joke
I’ve said “I’m the towniest town” etc in 2 town games, I was making a callback for fun
This was a continuation of the joke
Where I’m like going “oh nooo don’t do that, I am so obviously towny”
While also looking susp as heck for again, a joke
I like to make psots like this alot as scum; calling something scummy without providing reason gives a solid foundation for later scum pushes. Possible guav is doing the same; but at the same time calls it thoughtless and dismisses it.
Would you say it was initial hedging?
But then they double down on it once they read more on me
Would you consider that natural progression or faking it?
I’m going to budge on that given regardless of alignment people aren’t typically nervous about one vote
I would say the more votes I get, the less I would feel motivated to read back and progress in the game
I know it sucks but I joined this game when only Arctic was in and wasn’t even sure it’d start
I was reluctant to join but I am enjoying the game, just worried about Wild West happening again because I can’t get caught up on posts
I don’t think Gar (and by extension you because you said you agree) is right about this but I’m not sure how I can further explain why
I just don’t think Caitlin asking a question with a fairly obvious answer makes her scum
Why can’t you further explain it?