Stratagem-27 FM - GAME OVER - MAFIA VICTORY

[sulit]

am I like the only person that thinks this is weird

[sulit]

idk maybe I just don’t know may that well if that is May

I have played with magnus but not with May but I haven’t played recently enough to remember how magnus plays and their dumb bit thing is making it more confusing

[Magnus]

Yes. You’re getting confused again

[sulit]

wow I really wonder why

[May]

(Hi it’s me May outside of the bit here to be clear this is me saying “Magnus impersonating my gameplay and tone means they’re hard to read”)

[Magnus]

@sulit

@Magnus

Although, Maynus putting suspicion onto Garfooled is relevant to one of their comments later down

I don’t find that too convincing when the original reason for their suspicion is illogical at best and absolutely ridiculous at worst

I think it’s absolutely ridiculous by design

@sulit

@Magnus

From where I’m standing, this looks like Maynus”s interpretation was that Litten had prewritten his opening post, and while it’s slightly towny (meaning more towny than not) that he followed through with posting it, such an act isn’t exactly clearing. You aren’t really disagreeing with Maynus here?

No, I’m not disagreeing with WhoeverMagnusMay

I’m saying that, as they had recognized that Litten’s post was towny, the logic should have extended to that Litten probably would not be pushing hard to play this optimally if they were mafia, leading to a stronger townread. The logic seems off to me. It’s not disagreement.

Seeing how I’m still playing the devil’s advocate, which is absolutely a new position for me and not a sign of me being argumentative… Litten is the 2021 best Mafia player on this site

@sulit

@Magnus

This is a weird conclusion because it suggests Maynus had a stronger sense of distrust on Garfooled’s slot than what was initially expressed. I haven’t personally checked the votecounts at that time, but if a quickly growing wagon is indicative of a non pure wagon, and the person you suspect is being pushed, it’s a logical conclusion to make. I have a different gripe with this post than you do

What’s your different gripe?

I said it. We agreed it was a weird post, but you had a different reason

[Magnus]

Coward

[Magnus]

@sulit

Also you guys are making me grumpy and annoyed I strongly dislike your bit and I think it’s dumb.

[sulit]

Kiiruma Eliza

[May]

And Litten.

[sulit]

sorry

if you guys wanna mess around that’s fine but you’re actively making yourselves harder to read if you are town

[Magnus]

Okay I’m fine with that

[Magnus]

I’m not planning on throwing the game for the bit, I’m just trying to have fun so Mafia games don’t stagnate.
I can’t speak for Maynus. I think they’re also just having fun

[sulit]

well now you’re making me feel bad

[sulit]

I’m still scumreading wolfy behavior I’m not trying to decipher what’s part of a bit and what isn’t

[May]

@Magnus

I’m not planning on throwing the game for the bit, I’m just trying to have fun so Mafia games don’t stagnate.
I can’t speak for Maynus. I think they’re also just having fun

Given my gameplay has barely changed at all, I’m not too concerned about the bit interfering with things. Honestly, I think impersonating you has significantly improved my readability, since it means I’ve mostly restrained myself from posting fluff.

The thing that makes me feel slightly off at reading May here is the change to their tone specifically, but I’ll get over that. There are still material actions to take a look at.

[Garfooled]

I just don’t want their excuse to be “I’m roleplaying as someone else” for whatever we cook up.

How do you go about combatting that? I’m not even reading them based on meta.

[sulit]

just what I said

looking for wolfy behavior regardless of bits

Mays original post is still wolfy in my opinion

[sulit]

my read doesn’t really change unless they want to argue most of that post was for the bit and they actually end up convincing me somehow

[Garfooled]

Magnus’s response to my earlier arguments was basically
“May does this, they test reactions”
Like okay? I’d have to take their word on it though for that response to work.

(Argh wording, idk why I keep obsessing over it, don’t mind the edits)