Please do not do two spies
ALSO wooooooooooo 2/2 game cans
3 Likes
I guess
I think in that case you would only want it half closed
E.g. the fact that pres bomber Doctor engineer and spies are in play definitely needs to be public
1 Like
Lmao I am so good at hosting
called itttt
1 Like
But presence of roles like coy boy shy guy security smuggler are ok to be un revealed, and similar roles
But don’t put Dr. Boom into the game and not reveal it. I don’t know what sane person puts Dr boom into the game in the first place but
i reckon we would have won this one considering as leader i knew bomber / engineer and i dont think reds in our room knew engineer
4 Likes
May is a deceptive succubus.
I guessed Marshal was Spy, Zug slipped to me that he was unconcerned about finding the President
1 Like
Why were all of you so bad at playing around Spies
A Coy Boy claim has straight up a 50/50 chance of being the Spy. Do not trust them. Tutuu and Icet I at least had to talk to for a while and share a bunch of information with, I did in fact have to wolf them
1 Like
I had this
Summary
Hi Hippo, I don’t want this meeting to be extremely long so it won’t be clear that we’re aligned but we have a lot to talk about. I’m preparing this copypasta debrief to speed things up
Icet is the Engineer, tutuu is the Bomber, they both revealed to me and only me Round 1 because I’m a gamer. I powerwolfed to get Icet elected leader, told him tutuu claimed Negotiator, and ordered him to stay in his room and send tutuu over to the other room. If anybody ever learns that tutuu and Icet both claimed to me, then I will basically be outed as Spy, and they will try to meet up and talk
Our goal is to delay that happening as long as possible, as if we play this right I think we can prevent them from ever being able to cardshare, and secondarily to simply not end with the Bomber and the President in the same room. Icet should, if he’s listening to me and hasn’t been overthrown, stay in the National Archives. We don’t want tutuu to be passed over this round, and we also don’t want anybody who can tell Icet tutuu is Bomber passed over this round, so either Blues or people who can’t have learned tutuu’s claim via the tracked whispers
We’ll only know who our best choices to send as hostages are once the whispers are down on the table. Me, Cyanide, pigeon probably (unless he is specifically Spy who still had a super long convo with Carroty), Hazard probably, anybody who’s Blue or doesn’t whisper tutuu/people who whisper tutuu
Because of how my whispers worked out, I didn’t get the chance to communicate any of this to the Blues in the other room. They only know I am Spy and I asked for Icet to be leader, stay put, and send over the specific list of hostages they did. I want to get somebody over there to tell them what’s going on so they can keep Icet shut over there - CarrotyReaper is our Security, so she’ll be a great help there
Here are my full notes, which you do not have to read all of right now:
Definite Red:
IcetFeelsPain (LEADER) - Red Engineer, only claimed to me Round 1, has orders to stay planted in National Archives, I told him tutuu claimed Negotiator
tutuu - Red Bomber, only claimed to me Round 1, we need to keep him in the Supreme Court as long as possibleProbable Red:
Ash - claims Red Coy Boy, both Icet and tutuu think that he is the Blue Spy
Marluna - probably Red Shy Guy, claimed Red unprompted and has been sharing Red-beneficial information
Leafia - blank space, talked briefly and apparently unhelpfully to Carroty (Blue), >rand Red, pigeon/Carroty whispered after the conversation so he should have more infoDefinite Blue:
CarrotyReaper - Blue Security, has talked to me/Leafia/pigeon in order
May - B) already won the game spiritually who CARES what happens nextProbable Blue:
Chomps - colour shared Blue with tutuu
thepigeonnyc - revealed as Blue to Marluna after she claimed Red, talked to Carroty and Leafia, probably has all Carroty’s info if real
Hazardwaste - claiming Blue Shy Guy unprompted, I claimed Red to him and revealed as Red trying to claim Co Boy, realised I fucked up, softed Bomber to get out of it, he thinks that I am the Bomber
Cyanide’s notes if you don’t have all of them already:
Zug - Red
Gocj - Blue Vanilla
Marshal - Blue ??? (Claims Coy)
Meme - Red, claimed bomber (maybe engineer?)
Jane - had a 30 minute whisper with meme and called it productive. avoid.
Ishmael - claiming negotiator according to marshal
hippo - doctor
Siobhan - marissa didnt say anything but nfl is sorta like basketball so prolly red
pigeon - blue
hazard - claims blue shy
And here’s my best guess at the current role list, with confirmed roles bolded:
Blue Team
President - Cyanide
Doctor - Hippo
Coy Boy - Marshal? [claim]
Shy Guy - Hazard
Spy - May
Security - CarrotyReaper
Agent - ???
Negotiator - ???
Vanilla - Gocj
Vanilla - ???Unknown Blue [3]: Chomps, pigeon, childe [one could be Red Spy]
Red Team
Bomber - tutuu
Engineer - Icet
Coy Boy - Ash
Shy Guy - Marluna
Spy - ??? [could be Marshal/Chomps/perhaps pigeon]
Smuggler - ???
Agent - ???
Negotiator - ???
Vanilla - ???
Vanilla - ???Memekingpizza, Zugzwang, Jane?, Leafia?, Siobhan?, Aleph?
Plus Zug claiming Agent to me. And I was pretty sure Marissa was the Spy for aforementioned Zug reasons
1 Like
In our next mafia game if you don’t catch the entire wolf team d1 I’m mischopping you. Never trusting you again. You broke my trust and heart. You deserve no trust.
DONT POST THAT NOT IN PUBLIC
1 Like
NO MORE
DONT POST ANY MORE I BEG
1 Like
I am less disappointed in you, who took several hours and a bunch of Red-beneficial information and planning to get to the point of sharing your role, than Hippo, who said he claimed and shared all his info to three different Spy candidates, if that helps
3 Likes
Ahhh phew 
(I legit crave your approval thanks for not being too disappointed at me 
)
Anyway yeah nya powerwolfing. I’m quite proud of my performance during Round 1. @Zugzwang I intentionally held you waiting in that whisper so you couldn’t whisper anybody else, cause I didn’t want you to find out that tutuu was the Bomber. It kept you a safe candidate to send over to the other room without revealing to Icet that I was the Spy
2 Likes
1 Like