Umineko FM: Land of the Golden Witch - Thread 1 - Days 1 & 2

Forum Games Completed
, ,
#1928

tbh part of my concern is that i got the sense katze as a wolf would just dance around folers and get away with anything, kinda like that org game but worse cuz it’s home turf

it’s therefore my solemn duty to hold them accountable with some light cyberbullying

on the whole i’ve basically switched from questioning if anyone in the game is a villager to questioning if anyone is a wolf, probably because i’ve been following along a 2000 post thread over 12 hours without re-reading anything and i’ve forgotten half of it at least already

1 Like
#1929

ye heisenberg’s iso is rough, sorry bud

kinda think he is w/w with min for the post I fry’d earlier (this one), it was out of nowhere and didn’t really hold up imo. and min’s left me feeling meh for no specific reason, similar to what visor said

nightingale’s posts have left very little impact on me

out 4 the night

lolbye

Umineko FM: Land of the Golden Witch - Thread 2 - Days 3-7
#1930

I’m not against the Heisenberg wagon as I have no idea about them.

#1931

I could pretend that I have some deep reads here, waking up to 700 posts reading them all and taking in nothing. Tells me that I’m going to suck even more then normal at finding wolves, . So is it possible to get a cliff notes version on why Heisenburg is top wagon by some distance because I never fully got the gist of that from reading.

I’m fully expecting to just get trolled in response to this, but ask regardless.

#1932

I instead offer a different bit of advice. pick someone to iso at random or whatever. and then post why they are town or wolf. No nulls, just do it. Except do this for 2-3 people. You don’t have to follow the hot topic of a thread or every person’s post to be useful in the long run, take it in bite sized chunks.

You can start with me if you like, it’s a fairly easy read.

#1933

Thats solid advice and more what I do in the later game, not day one. I will do that then, but not as random because I think the hot topic is important.

Umineko FM: Land of the Golden Witch - Thread 2 - Days 3-7
#1934

Why? You don’t even know why it is a hot topic. Maybe it’s dumb. Make a hot topic of your own.

Talk about how random person is super v and you want to mason with them or how someone with 0 wolves is wolfing it up

idk but don’t expect to be spoon fed stuff, you know? I get that it is a lot but you can’t just expect people to hand you stuff and it be useful.

Trust me I tried with Katze that did not work out.

#1935

When something has that many votes it should not be dumb, and even if dumb does not mean it is not worth looking into.

The 2nd part is pure playstyle / confidence and ablity to meme you will never find a game where I do any of that stuff, just not in my nature.

Anyway I’m not going to carry on this discussion, because I know with you its something I could potentially get stuck in all day, Going to iso instead.

1 Like
Umineko FM: Land of the Golden Witch - Thread 2 - Days 3-7
#1936

my god you people need to shut up

#1937

always W tbh

#1938

every time i’ve complained about the postcount i’ve been a villager and called a wolf for doing so immediately, try again

#1939

Anyway my spirit is a bit dampened but I’ll take my own advice. NO NULLS ALLOWED.

Nightingale - V. Actual analysis doesn’t move me a lot in this iso, not a lot of firm stances but haven’t met a lot of mafia who can fake this style for long without something cropping up. Heisen vote post was also beautifully worded and I like that.

Gorta - Token V read because you’re doing your best.

Gyrlander - W. Displayed an unpleasant self-awareness and only stayed long enough to say they would be around awhile and promise an OP role.

It’d be a shame if someone started a wagon on them and forced them into the spotlight and actually play.

VOTE: Gyrlander

#1940

I just don’t like complaining, but needing to rely on meta reads of yourself to parry a ‘always W tbh’ post is also…

always W tbh

#1941

Yeah I can see why people don’t like Heisenburg after that for 74 posts, they was very little actual content and any sign of deep thought. Also the voting seems a little bit random with no rhyme or reason apart from the ones on Rue. I know that is something a lot of people do though just vote wherever.

Something that bothers me is the hyper focus on Rue’s push on Zorvo, I’m not going into my views on that debate since I made them clear. What bothers me is that Katze was doing the same thing as Rue in a even more forceful manner imo, but got zero backlash or criticism off Heisenburg. They bring Katze up much later in the day, but it seems like they were avoiding talking about Katze and just trying to force all the attention on Rue which makes no sense to me. Imo both should of being treated in the same way.

Not much else to say apart from that they is nothing else stand out just a lot of memes.

Umineko FM: Land of the Golden Witch - Thread 2 - Days 3-7
Umineko FM: Land of the Golden Witch - Thread 2 - Days 3-7
#1942

#1943

#1944

i cited the meta because people who think that complaining about the postcount is a classically wolfy behaviour ought to be shown they’ve been living a lie

#1945

VOTE: Heisenburg

Doing this until they explain why they treated 2 people so differently, who were doing the same thing and also have more actual overall content and proof of thought.

Umineko FM: Land of the Golden Witch - Thread 2 - Days 3-7
Umineko FM: Land of the Golden Witch - Thread 2 - Days 3-7
#1946

I could go for a third but actually you are missing MY meta that I jokingly wolf read negativity.

Because this thread is bonkers and I have no desire to read it all until much later.

#1947

Wolves prefer more post heavy days especially early, its a lot easier to hide in the chaos. Also a lot more chance that random town will do what everyone will think is a wolf slip then all jump on them without mercy.

Or maybe that’s just my experience with Mafia games.