Umineko FM: Land of the Golden Witch - Thread 2 - Days 3-7

[sufdaddy]

achro/katze

[GaulSoodman]

@GaulSoodman

imo if katze is your highest wolfread i think reading her iso and looking for who seems partnered with her is probably the best move imo

i know you said you didn’t really wolf read her seriously but it’s a good thought exercise

generally helps me a lot when I sun into heavy games is to assume someone is a wolf/villager and see where I go

[Sadbi]

I will take it

[WindwardAway]

@GaulSoodman

@WindwardAway

Ruby

(unless you mean other than Ruby)

I meant other than ruby lol sorry

Katze but I’m not sure if she counts
Guava maybe next
There are just a bunch of players I haven’t read at all that probably contain wolves BECAUSE I have not read them and have no other solid scumreads besides Ruby
Which is why I’m kind of shaky on answering this; seems kind of unfair to spit random names of people I haven’t even tried to solve.

[GaulSoodman]

no

my sons couldn’t do this to me

[Sadbi]

[min]

I think her posts are actively protown especially in the current game state

It’s not a super confident one but it’s one I still wanna say bc I don’t think her posting is garbage like ppl think it is

[Gorta]

@GaulSoodman

Gorta this attitude loses games

the chances of the entire wolf team being incredibly coordinated is very unlikely, fundamentally giving LHF slots a pass just because of what happened on day 1 is a very bad idea, especially if the only reason they’re LHF is because they got trounced during the day.

also there were many other town players that wolves could have killed who were loud and could potentially be correct who weren’t hally or spf. Additionally spf was probably strongman killed, why would wolves waste a strongman if they were mostly incorrect on their reads

this reads as confbias against rue imo

but that’s where you are wrong, for a stunt like that d1 there has to be some level of coordination

@GaulSoodman

is there any reason except “she didn’t vote a wolf”

if that’s the case why are you just letting me lead town

why are you so defensive of Rue?

@GaulSoodman

again my problem is there’s literally no way I can read this except as confbias because if you actually read eod1 you shouldn’t be just accepting of me shutting your rue defence or leading the town lol

I’ll read you next I think because there is a chance you are powerwolfing tbh

@GaulSoodman

because i attacked your push directly and fear because you think if we go for a PoE you’re next

WRONG, I had this read before you even defended rue today

[katze]

probably

i dont mind being uncharitable on a wasted day

worst case scenario im wrong and it turns into a v/v tunnel ala arctic11

but i self resolve and thus care even less

id rather push buttons while this day is ongoing than be stagnant

[WindwardAway]

@katze

@WindwardAway

So in order as I have them:

Memes
Zorvo
Gyr
Zack
Phraze (pure null, did not read this slot at all)
Outedwolf (pure null, did not read this slot at all)
Guava
Katze

idk i guess its only a select subset of players but its not particularly enthusing that this is her reasoning for top scumread of that grouping

i will reserve actual judgement when the name pool is wider

Literally none of that list contains a hard scumread from me because I haven’t fucking read the game in its entirety with all of the context that I should have
You’re top scumread of that group
If I commit to reading all the slots I haven’t read, maybe you won’t be top scumread, who knows

[katze]

@WindwardAway

Literally none of that list contains a hard scumread from me

hence the actual judgement being reserved

i realized while writing that post that it was basically all weak snaptakes because you’re barely caught up

[WindwardAway]

@Achromatic

what was your take away of Brad’s wolf game?

He sounds like he’s dead inside
And even if he manages to pull it together for a while, as soon as he gets pushed he goes back to sounding dead inside
Lol

[Sadbi]

Oh I know it’s just funny how low people’s standards are for us.

[WindwardAway]

@GaulSoodman

the interesting thing to me was that her reasons for townreading Seth are far better than the reasons for townreading guillo but Seth is lower than guillo

i don’t know what it means I’m a bimbo but it means something

It’s because the most recent game I played with both of them was a game in which Guillo was town and Seth was wolf

[WindwardAway]

I think it’s a weird disparity due to comparison and also due to knowing what Seth specifically is capable of doing as a wolf

[Achromatic]

actually I am not doing much right now, can someone link that recent zorvo scum game I will do a little bit of confbiasing meta

[WindwardAway]

@katze

@WindwardAway

until tomorrow if you’re alive

as per my claim i die n4 not n3

I can’t read, fuck

[Sadbi]

Damn that was brutal

[Sadbi]

I’m glad I can coast till I die.

[WindwardAway]

@GaulSoodman

@GaulSoodman

imo if katze is your highest wolfread i think reading her iso and looking for who seems partnered with her is probably the best move imo

i know you said you didn’t really wolf read her seriously but it’s a good thought exercise

generally helps me a lot when I sun into heavy games is to assume someone is a wolf/villager and see where I go

I misread when she said she’d die so yeah
I will actually commit to reading her slot properly lol