Umineko FM: Land of the Golden Witch - Thread 2 - Days 3-7

[Rue]

[can we just hammer]

[sufdaddy]

@KimWexler

@katze can you explain the thought that me and zack are not v/v

you don’t even scumread him iirc?

@KimWexler

@Sadbi

He really is just coming off as a power wolf. Nothing in his eod is from town mindset esp the hop from visor to katze. It seemed like he wanted whatever wagon to happen to protect Geyde and didn’t matter who it was.

it might help to read the rest of my posts, i don’t have many on day 1

@katze

wolves likely have some sort of vested interest, not necessary to interject if v/v but possible

if zack v i think hes >rand to be right on you
if you’re town then–

well, i guess you raise a valid point

yeah i don’t really buy this lol
i think you just feel the only way you don’t die here is by townsiding so you dropped that and it was a bit of a blunder

I do think Arctic may have been correct that the not v/v read was wolfy (though not because it was townsiding lol)

especially since it was wrong and encouraged two villagers to keep going at it. one of the classics

[GaulSoodman]

no i really want to hear from windward first

[GaulSoodman]

@WindwardAway

do you have any games where you’ve subbed in mid game as a villager or as a wolf

i think i need to compare them to here imo

[sufdaddy]

what’s your min read

I’ve just dropped it because Arctic seemed convinced they were town but they still don’t really seem towny to me

[GaulSoodman]

how’d you find that post

as in what we’re you looking for

[sufdaddy]

i remembered katze making that read and went to see what artic said about it

[GaulSoodman]

@GaulSoodman

i think min’s handling of arctic and heisenberg was very good

min handled arctic in a way that guaranteed massive amounts of damage to his own flimsy reputation, and had clearly much like me basically only really talked to arctic and acted like his hype man which is why he had similar reactions to me yesterday

I also think that min trying to use meta from Deus Ex to read geyde is also a decent look since I think a wolf would actually bother to check the game itself. I also think that the way min handled the wagon on heisenberg was also decent since I know min can powerwolf and their arguments against heisenberg wagon and for katze were very meh. This is despite them pushing katze since the very start.

@sufdaddy

[GaulSoodman]

i see

you seem kinda aimless is the thing

not very hyped up if you get me

[sufdaddy]

true lol

I’m trying to give a shit

[GaulSoodman]

how 2 help?

overall really really do wanna solve you and wind today cause if you’re town and in the PoE we’re gonna be fucked later but if you’re wolves then I don’t need to worry and I can just stop posting and let Jesus take the wheel

you get me?

[GaulSoodman]

do you still believe in your achro push

it’s kinda sputtered out

why were you looking at what katze said

[GaulSoodman]

do i wanna take the zach pill and go to ikea

or throw it out the window and burn the ikea to the ground

or take the zach pill but burn down the ikea or vice versa

you get the dilemma im in rn

[sufdaddy]

I couldn’t keep up at all d2, and going back to read 10k posts on discourse is incredibly daunting when people are still posting a bunch today (that I’ve missed some of too) and I have other stuff going on. been a long time since I was in a game this active

feel like I’ve just been plopped in the poe and don’t know where to start, achro seems wolfy but I could be wrong, I got the impression he is unlikely to be aligned with Ruby? so if she’s a wolf I’m not sure where I’d go. just having a hard time getting a grasp of the game. no one really seems to think I am correct on anything lol so idk

would my alignment impact your reads either way, sorry if I already asked this

[sufdaddy]

it just came to mind, there’s no grand explanation

and I kinda wanted to sponge Arctic a bit because I’d feel bad if I mislunched him and didn’t respect his reads to some extent - even if I do think his perspective was warped for various reasons

[GaulSoodman]

@sufdaddy

would my alignment impact your reads either way, sorry if I already asked this

yes especially if you and wind are the same alignment

[sufdaddy]

why does that matter

[GaulSoodman]

i gave some questions to wind

would you mind answering them as well

out of these names, would you mind ordering these names from most villagery at the top to least villager on the bottom

outedwolf
zack
guava
gyr
katze
phraze
memes
zorvo

there are some players who seem to be leading the village, if you had to name only one who is a wolf out of the loudest players today.

name a wolf please
any wolf
first name that comes to your mind when you think of a wolf

ruby dies and flips wolf, in the night you’re modpeeked villager. Everyone decides to make you the official Town Leader Who We Will Be Sheeping, what is your plan of action (please don’t say I don’t know, give first thing that pops into your head)

same circumstances as second question but ruby is a villager, what changes.

[GaulSoodman]

because if you and wind are villagers then I’m pretty sure katze is a wolf

and if you’re both villagers I can’t really guess who the other wolves are with any certainty

[Zorvo]

Since I made my readslist.