Umineko FM: Land of the Golden Witch - Thread 2 - Days 3-7

[guavagudetama]

Okay, what do you wanna talk about?

[WindwardAway]

@katze

eh

its too early in the day to say for sure, i feel like today was going to turn into you vs jack depending on what brad said

if min is a wolf id absolutely be looking at jack more than anyone else, unless ur also a wolf in which case lol

That’s probably true to an extent, yes
Which is why I tagged both of them from the hood to ask their opinions on whether our chat might have leaked
I will say one thing:
if you are town, and your check that Brad was blocked is accurate, then I think there was a sellsword-type role on GGhana and not a direct block on Brad
Because for one, the wolf roleblocker is dead
And for two, I believe Brad said something like “I’m bodyguarding GGhana” and if it was leaked elsewhere without a source name, the blocker would’ve known GGhana was the target but not who was going to protect him.
And seeing as Brad is a bodyguard anyway and not a doctor, it doesn’t matter very much whether he or GGhana dies because they were both widely townread as far as I gathered, BUT if the wolves didn’t know that the bodyguard was Brad, they could have been afraid of letting a PoE town slot flip and then they wouldn’t be able to agenda them.

Sorry this is just a whole lot of rambling and I will check the exact wording but it is something that crossed my mind, I’ve just been trying to figure out how to word this.

[Sadbi]

Who is the mole in hood and if there is a mole.

Was Brad rbed?

Was katze lying?

[Rue]

@WindwardAway [I] was informed that the mastermind chat would have messages from other private chats. Does that affect your theory at all?

[Host_Account_2]

Vote Count

---

WindwardAway (2): guavagudetama, min
min (2): katze, Rue

Not Voting (11): BradLand, Gorta, Gyrlander, Outedwolf, Zorvo, Jackrito, sufdaddy, Sadbi, Memes, WindwardAway, Achromatic

[guavagudetama]

Who’s in hood again?
(Like I mentioned I was majorly detached from the game yesterday so if it was said then I probably didn’t read it
And if it was said today… sorry )

[Jackrito]

Well I likely die after that also because of the whole dome situation. The only good situation for me is Wind being a wolf. It just seems a great way to time waste 3 days potentially. It was better to leave it between me and Wind.

[WindwardAway]

@Jackrito

I hate this situation because the only way I come good out of this is, if Wind is a wolf, if Min is town the debate will carry on tomorrow of me or Wind, if Min is a Wolf it looks like a attempt to save me. I just don’t feel like this good for game state unless Wind is a wolf which even with my vote eariler I’m not even sold on

Yeah
I’m just gonna keep trying to solve you through the rest of today so I can get a correct read by the time i need to leave a legacy
Cause if you’re town then I don’t want people to turbo you after I flip

[Gyrlander]

VOTE: min

For now. Might change later.

[WindwardAway]

Brad jack me

[Sadbi]

What are Jack’s interaction like with Geyde and Ruby (and visa versa)

What are Winds interaction like with Geyde and Ruby (and visa versa)

The timing of katze mech clear claim on Brad is bothering me.

[WindwardAway]

I wasn’t even in the game till yesterday and Geyde was very much dead

[katze]

@WindwardAway

if you are town, and your check that Brad was blocked is accurate, then I think there was a sellsword-type role on GGhana and not a direct block on Brad

my check is teeeeechnically a little bit ambiguous

in the sense that this is a possibility, yes

idk if its likely, a wolf ascetizer/rolestopper+strongman as well as a roleblocker seems overkill, whatever it was i expect it to be limited shot

or a villager

[Sadbi]

I’m just bothered that katze didn’t bring up the green check on Brad till after wind.

[WindwardAway]

I only interacted with Ruby once when she came in and basically gave up defending herself
I didn’t know she’d spent the previous day in PoE too so I asked her for a defense and she said she already gave it plus her reads if I iso her D2
And then I never read it lmao
Because Brad had told us already in the hood that Ruby was his counterclaim

[min]

This is why I think people complaining are probably overplaying it tbh

An upper poe player giving a gladiator to themselves is not anything I’d do as wolf especially when 2 of my teammates died but for some reason y’all are gonna believe it is as hard as you can because you’re either wolves or confbiased so hard you are ignoring all logic

Winds previous slot did nothing remotely to solve the game

winds biggest pusher(? died and was even strongmanned/the bodyguard on him was possibly roleblocked

winds previous slot was actively being solved by night (who was even flipping their read to show this) and night got bled

both night and Gaul didn’t want jack dead and even village read him. Why would he murder either of them in result of this especially when it seems 2 of his wolfmates have been bussed already?

Use logic. Wind is probably a wolf, and even if she isn’t I will continue to have her in my rolecard which is actively extremely protown because when she is town she is a fairly good reader. You kill me instead, you don’t get any of that and you kill a villager

[Rue]

VOTE: WindwardAway

[WindwardAway]

What kind of villager blocks Brad though, who tf was scumreading him
cause I subbed in late but even I thought he was towny right off the bat

[Rue]

@WindwardAway

What kind of villager blocks Brad though, who tf was scumreading him

I was, but I didn’t block him.

[katze]

i didnt want to open up the day with it and i didnt expect someone else to open up sod with “I HAVE A GREEN CHECK ON BRAD”, i also didnt want to flat out claim my role immediately either for another reason but once brad claimed his own role that became null

but yeah, i get that concern, shouldnt matter as i probably self resolve tonight