Worst Role Tournament Discussion Thread

Pretty sure one of my votes won’t make a difference. I voted Peregrine Mendicant over Death Miller.

Objectively, Night-immune Executioner is way less worse than any Death Miller. However, in Homestuck FM, I randed as Jack Noir, the Night-immune Serial Killer that still lost. So yeah, I am biased against that role.

1 Like

i also voted for PM

1 Like

w u p s

Whats up with the 3 way

Wait what the hell does Weaver do?

great question

Time travel in mafia is a concept…


…oh, and it is kinda iffy whether BotP in Scenario 2 implies whether Weaver can target two people at once or not, because it says “you may target that player again”.

To be honest, I probably need to check out Effect 3 in more detail.

i forgot to post that particular matchup in round 1

2 Likes

I personally subscribe to DM far worse than PM mainly because PM is just a standard bad neutral while DM bricks games incredibly easily

I feel like Cyan should win against Ed the Wolf, simply because it’s hella more annoying to play and also so much better if thr player who rands it has no idea who the hell Cyan is

Ditto. EtW forces the player to post an “-ed” word every day. Cyan forces the player to go through a database of 20k posts, and use “useful” posts from those posts.

Even though it is public knowledge, at the very least you get the freedom to vote and say what you want.

Also
Fun fact

I spend an hour searching for revenant

3 Likes

Just one hour? Wow

I’m good at what I do
But still it’s frustrating that basically nobody posted it anywhere

1 Like

Well ofc no one posted it, Grand Idea has some resemblance of quality.

1 Like

Not a lot of quality, since I posted Lich at some point, but at least some quality

1 Like

still dissapointed I didn’t get to submit Comintern