Bland & Flavorless Mountainous 15er - Mafia Winnered

Forum Games Completed
,
#2241

One thing that trips me up from that viewpoint is why molly wasn’t killed, she pushed otter the hardest on day 1. I guess that would be because it would implicate otter more? But I could see this being a W/W thing, which would explain why molly pivoted to Eliza on day 2 instead of continuing the push.

I don’t want to provide far-fetched takes like these and base my entire solve around them, just going to leave this here as a reminder (I said this before).

#2242

You can shit on my read all you want, but if it’s correct I’m going to act extremely fucking annoying for like at least 3 minutes in postgame

1 Like
#2243

Tbf, the last time I let you strongarm a read on somebody I townread, they flipped town and I felt awful about it.

#2244

3 minutes is nothing compared to what we will hear from seth if arete is a wolf

2 Likes
#2245

:face_holding_back_tears:

1 Like
#2246

To be completely fair, Seth sometimes has unreasonably good instinct. I was in a game with him where he had an SK read on someone on day 2 when we didn’t even know an SK was in the game. The player was indeed SK.

#2247

I haven’t forgotten

#2248

Oh, and now Arete, a third person I want to talk to, isn’t here either.
Spectacular EoD hour.

#2249

VOTE: otter

#2250

Gee thanks.

#2251

I’m giving you my vote today on three conditions Vul

  1. If Arete is a wolf you are going to forget the Kaguya sama game
  2. If Arete is still alive in lylo and I am not you will at least reconsider your read and look at them again with more scrutiny
  3. If Arete is actually town you don’t get to gloat at me postgame because in the end I’m tabling it for now to kill someone I think is also almost always a wolf
#2252
ok but actually though
1 Like
#2253
maybe we should make up for not doing that d2 I like Neon
1 Like
#2254

By far the most incriminating thing about arete is that they held the decisive vote on Magnus and could have killed otter instead

Nothing else even compares

Magnus SHOULD have been obvious town, if not to everyone else, at least to arete.

#2255

Okay, level with me for a second. Why should Magnus have been obvious town and why was the wagon on him such an atrocity? I did have him as town, but I don’t think our logic on why he was town aligns at all.

#2256

I don’t constantly shit on people for past mistakes, I re-evaluate every time it’s warranted, and I don’t gloat postgame basically ever. You have all three promises by default because I just don’t do those things.

1 Like
#2257

His iso all the way up to his posts on zorvo and into his read list are literally just textbook town Magnus

I went in reading with the blessing of hindsight but still

#2258

Okay, fair, I suppose. I’ve never seen Magnus’s new wolfgame, but fair. Now… should Arete really have known that? Do they have experience with each other?

#2259

You literally just referenced kaguya sama like 10 minutes ago :joy_cat:

It doesn’t need to be constant, I mean like forget it happened entirely

#2260

I did that less to shit on you and more to justify me going against you harder this time around.

I can’t make myself forget a game, but I will stop referencing it.