Oh no.
2 Likes
oh yes
So the Magician can register as specific evils, gotcha.
Figured their ability only worked during Minion info and that was it.
1 Like
their ability has the âthinkâ keyword so you can theoretically have all of the leeway to tell them anything that would help keep up the ruse
1 Like
I kinda hate this.
1 Like
honestly you probably should
itâs an extreme stretch but there is technically precedent of simulating other playersâ abilities working to lunatics / drunks / marionettes
1 Like
Itâs very yes but donât
2 Likes
i had a dream that i pulled the zombuul token and i had a spy & mm
i remember killing an innkeeper
we were nearing the end of the game with me and the mm alive
1 Like
That sure is one strong Pixie.
1 Like
yep
with the downside that until their role dies they have to feed a lot of false info to town in order to get the strong ability
bogus exorcist picks? bogus courtiier ability? bogus preacher picks?
on a mastermind day any one of these could accidentally lose good the game on the spot
2 Likes
I donât know why, but Snitch feels out of place to me.
There isnât a Poppy Grower or Magician, Fang Gu or Lilâ Monsta. If thereâs a Snitch, they just claim the Minions got three bluffs and thatâs that. Just feels kinda lacking.
Pukka + Mayor and Barber is kind of icky
this script is kinda geared more towards forum play where whisper tracking is possible
overall my reasoning for including snitch is that
even if it seems like it doesnât do much, it can get help out socially-good-reading minions operate on their own without being able to be hunted down with the âneedâ to speak to the demon early
and for a minion like the mastermind or the scarlet woman, that detachment can be extremely precious
i agree with it being sorta weak for an outsider on the script but having that extra info can give them a confidence boost that theyâre not gonna get screwed down the line so i dont think its invalid
1 Like
I think this is okay. A Pukka is fairly detectable, and if nothing points to either No Dashii or Po and you get to F3 with an alive Mayor you just donât go for a Mayor win.
As for Barber⌠I think that depends on how Pukka / Barber works? If the Barber is poisoned, dies and then becomes healthy, would the Demon make a pick?
barber i get but like
honestly i like them both enough for other reasons that
idk
barber im never taking off because the barber swap can be fatal to goodâs hold on the game
pukka im not as solid on but honestly
i dont know what id replace it with
i just think that with stuff like gossip/exorcist/preacher it makes solving those just a bit more complicated in a way that I like having in consideration for the good team given how strong those roles are
pukka + mayor is kinda just âtough luckâ
1 Like
nope
might bootleg that interaction if i run it but RAW
the barber dies oisoned
then becomes healthy
so nothing happens
2 Likes
It could be worse.
Heretic / Pukka.
2 Likes
pukka hits the heretic going into f3