BOTC/BOTF Discussion Thread 2

i had a funny idea.
without saying publicly the funny idea
i have three ideas of the script i wanna run but i want to check with the botc crowd what they think would be the best script




2 normal scripts, 1 Homebrew

hold on let me get a better pic for the homebrew

okay i havent looked at the others but i can pick apart midnight oasis all day
canni pg :nauseated_face:
canni golem :interrobang:
golem psycho :rage:
canni prof :face_vomiting:
engi al-had :sheep:
engi vigor :unamused:

and i also hate poppy grower and psychopath and poisoner like, in general, even without any interactions

demon chasers actually doesnt look half bad although i dont like clockmaker on it due to the actually quite small amount of possible misinfo, chef is probably lots better
i dont love lunatic in general but its fine
i hate hag/lleech personally but its fine
its not like oasis which has half the script being questionable interactions

how is gorard keay or whatever an outsider

and how are half of those townsfolk roles townsfolk

i probably would not play the magnus archives one just because im really squeamish on horror and the flavor triggers that

okay most of the townsfolk aren’t that bad but how is the vast a townsfolk

that player could be evil

how in the world would you compare a good player helping good win to an evil player helping evil win. which one you say helped their faction more seems arbitrary. might as well just flat out admit that role’s a negative feedback mechanism that’s the storyteller philosophy anyway

i have no clue honestly
i agree that its a negative feedback mech and i dont really like that

hm if that role’s in play would it actually be disadvantageous for good players to help their faction win in the early game. food for thought

the demons are meant to not stay. the clockmaker will find where the demon started. not where it finished

oasis is just funny and its the best alhad script i know

i suppose the same applies to evil players but that’s touchier

read the fabeled

Vast can drunk the demon

i know that’s why jurgen leitner is an outsider. what about gerard keay

1 Like

look at the fabeled <3

wait i had goldfish memory