BotF I.I - Hand of Darkness - Good wins

Hes not gonna acceptn

Well he would have learned 3 bluffs right so why would he claim choirboy/puzzlemaster to me

Check me or Intensify, preferably me

So

let’s say Mist is real

he listens to his bluff

Why would this occur that he claims Choirboy with Mist around?

He claimed Choirboy/Puzzle/Jugger at first then juggler/Choir then asked to be juggled as puzzlemaster

Why though?

im the one being suss’ed here no?

Shouldn’t I be checked

Wait that’s literally what I claimed to everyone on the first day except instead of Puzzlemaster it was Snitch

I couldn’t say. Seems obvious to me shark is evil but maybe maybe not a demon??? I don’t know

But then Snitch would back them up

Well yeah ofc but the thing is that if he’s a real evil he should have heard 3 bluffs from the supposed snitch right so why did he go with that claim instead of his 3 easy af bluffs

Okay so

I think the conclusion is that

Mist is just evil

Are you saying he deliberately double-claimed to seem like he didn’t have snitch bluffs

No I’m saying that

Even if wasn’t the Demon and a MInion, Snitch out of play characters would prevent doubleclaiming

Yeah

I am dead set on the fact Crich is likely to be fake but I can’t really point to anything and say why I just feel like it’s true.

so

literally only 3 possibilities for how this occurs:

Number 1: Shark isnt actually evil and ive been a gigabrain 100 IQ mastermind behind the shadows constructing everything very carefully so you all wouldnt suspect me

Number 2: Mist and Shark are both evil. Shark recieves bluffs either from being the Demon or Snitch, and one of them was Choirboy, so he uses that. Later then, Mist decides to use Choirboy as her bluff.

Number 3: Shark yolo’d and didnt follow any bluffs

Not to be biased

but im pretty sure it’s number 2

Where does that leave us though

Errr

Shark/Whysper/Mist/Wazza scumteam

I don’t hate it