poisoned evil athiest?
your widow poison didn’t take effect until the end of night 3
we had a full 20 hours of legal atheist time on our hands
fair enough
Atlas explained they were thinking about Philo’ing into the Sweetheart.
As Bellatrix explained it, while the Sweetheart’s ability, as an outsider, would be used to hinder Town, a Philo Sweetheart’s ability would be used to help town.
Were there any mechanically indicators leaning towards Mist instead of Marluna we missed, by the way? I thought it was left to social interpretation at the end.
1 Like
(Other than the Atheist thing, you’re claiming that didn’t influence the results.)
i mean the big thing was you just completely ignoring jake on d4
because if that info gets taken seriously it probably unravels the entire game
3 Likes
Would you believe a slanking traveller claiming a Widow’s call when it’s not on the script, when the Pit Hag was believed to be dead and nobody claimed Atheist?
3 Likes
The illusion of transparency is very much a thing.
1 Like
no but one that was by design two you didn’t even consider it for a second even when i tried to prompt you into thinking about it
(also crich had correctly cleared jake on setup spec too)
1 Like
honestly we didn’t have that much influence over the mechanical side of the game besides atheist
i think marluna no dashii was a valid world and the evil team did a good job of making that still valid with the information they claimed
the largest half-mech half-social thing you missed is that
if marluna is actually the demon going into f4, it doesn’t make much sense for her to reject wazza’s invitation when she would absolutely never with what she’s claiming as good
she never whispered wazza and wouldn’t know her alignment
it’d be much more logical for her to gamble on wazza being evil and confirming her
and it also doesn’t make much sense to reject the offer explicitly to avoid a thunderdome
then lie about it to make the thunderdome anyways
1 Like
When did you prompt me?
this sequence of stuff
the more of this thread i read the more confused i am
blood on the clocktower moment
2 Likes
what you need to understand is
im gay
4 Likes
If she accepted the invitation as No Dashii and Wazza was good, she’d see Marluna as the Demon and out her. There’s also technically a risk of death, so it did make sense to me why it’d be as such.
But that’s valid.
1 Like
Exactly as I intended
2 Likes
another half-mech-half-social thing
the entire social case you built on mist!town could have been destroyed by math simply being a bluff
the fact that the demon gets bluffs seemed to have been glossed over there
2 Likes
It wasn’t that I refused the possibility, I simply didn’t think of it. Nobody did, because it shouldn’t have seemed possible.
Because… Eliza wasn’t defending herself at all, and therefore YBW couldn’t be evil. Or so it seemed.
2 Likes