we would have not allowed that to happen because it would have been stupid
1 Like
YBW could’ve logically turned Mist into the Golem and double-killed right there.
Wait, no. I keep forgetting YBW wasn’t already a Psychopath.
Anyway, there are inherent problems with an evil Atheist, and while I think the Storytellers did well to limit the damage one could’ve done this game, I think the number of arbitrary what-ifs illustrates the problem with the idea. I would personally warn against putting a Pit Hag and Atheist in the same game again, if not the same script, but I’m not going to grudge Bellatrix and Amelia for it. This game was fun, had cool flavour, even if I wish other townsfolk had been more active. Congratulations to the evil team. I’m going to stop thinking about this before my brain turns to mush.
2 Likes
basically
ive been hashing it out in the unofficial botc over whether you should or shouldnt do this
and i think that atheist is a character to be run with the players in mind first
there are a lot of “what ifs” for sure, but most of those what ifs involve us letting things run unchecked
which we wouldn’t have done, because we cared about you as players
we wanted to use the atheist to make sure the players had a good time
i hope we didn’t breach any of your trusts’
2 Likes
See if your STs are smart about it, it’s no problem.
And if you don’t wanna do it, remember that with the Atheist powers you can zap the Atheist out of play.
4 Likes
I got called a liar 
1 Like
ybw had modest control over the rulebreaks because we thought that would let her have a good time
we did a crap ton of stuff behind the scenes to try to make sure everyone else had a good time as well
2 Likes
get screwed
Delayed Atheist is cool.
1 Like
i have good news for you then
night’s running a fm game whose flavor will be a sequel
its almost done and ready to be put into review
1 Like
How do you even write a sequel to this game?
1 Like
youll see
i dont want to spoil anything
1 Like
Foiled once again by a condescending arsehole
2 Likes
My plan is to die n1 in every FM game as Town, unless I have some way to protect myself (like randing Roleblocker, just consecutively rb Mafia it’s not that hard), and never die as Mafia. That’s everyone’s dream.
2 Likes
Stormcaught Drunk.
theres actually a legit fun script that has that
1 Like
wait how were you in your own game
1 Like
oh you just have a card nvm
2 Likes
guess that explains the XXI
I shoulda picked up on that mb
3 Likes