BotF XVII: U-Pick Your Poison - D6 - Lil Monsta (And the Evil Team) Wins!

The translation from live game to forums naturally cannibalizes some roles and makes it more difficult. You can hardly expect everyone to be present for a cult vote. In a F3 situation, my solution would be to make everyones vote final regardless of where in the circle they are. Similar to Lylo, or something like that.

It’s not perfect either but at least it prevents scenarios where a potential evil decides to hold the votes hostage like you’re describing.

2 Likes

ok
what if it happens earlier

If we were playing in person or online, votes would be locked in a clockwise motion. This is for every voting system in the game; nominations, exiles, cults, the works. We’re just trying to replicate that longform.

in f5, its valuable information

That’s a decent idea.

same thing could happen then, aswell

Either way, we aren’t in F5. We’re in F10.

2 Likes

magnus
its very flawed
you know it

WOOO F10 LET’S GOOO!!!
Imagine D1 F12, amirite? :laughing:

2 Likes

You’re free to propose an alternative.

Not really much in the way of doing it in an easier way I’m afraid. Aside from forcing votes to lock in early for cult votes. That’d work.

It’d still have issues, but eh. Closer to how it works in BOTC at least.

or just
have it work as
written?

once all good players say yes, its done, cults formed
thats how its written, and thats how the weird votesystem written up works too

Show me where

u know this isnt true

1 Like

That is per Cult Leader ability yes.

Also it does not matter wether or not you exile me, CL doesnt need only the alive good players, it needs all good players. Unless you show me how my logic was flawed im not joining the cult

ybw
just one thing, im not going to try and convince you

look at everyone who joined the cults, for me

Yeah, you go get 'em YBW!

every. single. one of those players
believed what we had to say

you’re the only one who’s pointlessly clinging onto it, and you’re not even a player