dead people don’t have abilities
he was dead when the thief was summoned
somethings not lining up claim wise
have we figured out why chomps survived or are we just chalking it up to some split steal chicanery
We dunno
I’m going to the iso mines
Based off Benguined information:
Kelsier/Chomps are evil or Benguined
Based off Aleph information: Icet is evil
Hm
Or aleph*
Also based off Benguined information, Chomps is not the demon, which means from their point of view the demon is in Aleph/Kelsier
Only way Icet is evil with Aleph is if they are on a team with benguined
Aleph is clearly the safest execution here if we want to make sure the game doesn’t end from executing a town. Either Icet was evil or Aleph is evil, and while Aleph claim sounds legitimate I don’t really want to risk the game ending in a loss off a town read because I’ve lost too many games from assuming someone is evil
I’m currently thinking Aleph
Regardless of my read on Aleph, it is the safest execution here, even if I think they are town, and I think we should be using some dead votes on this too.
VOTE: Aleph
I didn’t want to say this before because I thought it gave me a higher chance of surviving during the night, but if someone doesn’t die from execution, I become poisoned. I didn’t stop Chomps from dying, but currently I am poisoned. I think this is the best execution here, even if I think there’s a good chance they are town. Either they or Icet is evil, which means if we kill Aleph we guarantee the game goes to a final three, which benefits us a lot. Their behavior reminds me of the tracker? game? I think it was a tracker game? I was in with them a long time ago where they were town, in that game they acted similar to here, which is why I didn’t move to act until now. Even if they are town though, I think it’s probably the best move to execute them though, because I could be wrong!
Which btw I must say is a cool mechanic considering it interacted with a different ability
@benguinedparbecue from your perspective this should also be a good execution, you know chomps isn’t the demon, you know it’s between Kelsiher or Aleph, and you know there’s an evil between Icet and Aleph. It’s the safest execution regardless of anyone’s reads
i also know kelsier is evil though. i’d rather go for the guarantee
It doesn’t matter
The game will not end from executing alrph
i wish i could be so confident. i think now’s the part of the game where we have to start thinking about the possibility of a hidden outsider
you… did publicly target chomps at one point, didn’t you
there’s tinfoil to be had here
Nope, benguined and kelsier