CoD Feedback Thread

Game Discussion
#181

that’s actually in the works already

It has:

  • Silent ITAs
  • The Regal Lions stupid gimmick
  • No rules for spawning ala 10: chaos
  • Player submitted roles for each slot
  • Minor uPick elements
1 Like
#182

which one was this one

#183

The last 3 make a particularly deadly cocktail

1 Like
#184

‘target some number of players. they must vote amongst themselves to execute a player amongst themselves’

#185

oh that one

#186

it’s a player outside of themselves but yeah

#187

and it was 4 players

#188

so basically

  • a wolf role that can roll is PGO-izer arsonist even night vig that can bleed and activates a claimvig when it dies
  • king is 20% AD/20% Unshackled/Cult/20% survivor/20% random neut king/20% PK
  • game can begin as 9v7
  • all flips are flipless, to get the flips you must make a second vote to properly kill all the people you’ve exe’d and make them flip
  • wolves can fake host announcements
  • game is hard-broken by massclaim
  • king can randomly be converted into PK for no reason
  • and also we’re going back to the days of full feedback
2 Likes
#189

but are any of those as bad as secret unannounced scum ICs

1 Like
#190

WAIT I forgot ‘everyone can gladiate a player. at any time.’

#191

Because I don’t think it’s been mentioned in any reasonable capacity

Several people during CoD1 expressed a pointed dislike for the d1 exe, arguing that it was either actively terrible or unnecessary

1 Like
#192

I’m an asshole
Not satan

1 Like
#193

oh this reminds me of a thing on M451

#194

I do want the game to be some degree of playable

#195

that was a host decision
not a mechanic

#196

it didn’t have to be amongst themselves, it just gave full control over the execution to those four players, with no one else able to do anything

and they had to be unanimously, which was a problem when one of them replaced out (although 2 of the others were nontown so like it already would have been a problem)

1 Like
#197

i have no idea how it actually works but
the main gimmick is that only players who were targetted by night actions can be executed
also when a scum dies the scum can choose somebody to win the game and leave :wowee:

#198

That game wasn’t an SFoL
It was a large game

1 Like
#199

Didn’t

SFOL 61 had a gimmick that rewarded town for successfully executing scum

1 Like
#200

it had a number so it counts

(Derps GI 2 also counts even though it didn’t have a number. its number was 2.)

1 Like