Cookie Thread Act 1: A Cookie in Time

General
#24187

people on fol seem to enjoy roles that have 5+ abilities

3 Likes
#24188

They are serial button clickers

3 Likes
#24189

Thatā€™s why they are so obsessed with the old Danganronpa miscs
Those games are free action games but they are narrowly constrained within a ruleset
The game is imbalanced in that itā€™s nearly impossible for killers to win, but people think that they are smart cookies for figuring out how to do simple triangulation

2 Likes
#24190

You feel special because you have an ability set unique to you
Your own history
and you can decide what win condition you want to pursue

2 Likes
#24191

In reality, the Danganronpa miscs were some of the worst designed and worst implemented stuff piles in the history of the site
A truly terrible setup that was fundamentally broken
But it was hard to peel away all the lies and half-truths the concept and execution presented

2 Likes
#24192

This site, more than any other, falls in the face of a magician

2 Likes
#24193

This is why the best FoL setup is Lord of the Rings FM, a game that was just a shittily implemented stuff pile

2 Likes
#24194

thank you

1 Like
#24195

Kunaigeddon

2 Likes
#24196

The problems with each ā€œfixā€ to the DR killing problem:

  • Just give wacky powers - Kunaigeddon had a massive salt score
  • More reasons to lie - There is no reason to lie that can overcome the counterbalance of endangering your win condition
  • Give More Starting Items - This is the only method that works to make killing even remotely achievable but high salt score.
  • Anti-Grouping Mastermind Mechanics - This does not work. I donā€™t need to say why beyond ā€˜It requires other people to go with your plansā€™
2 Likes
#24197

F

#24198

I found this out the hard way

#24199

I have a comprehensive list of problems with Forum DR
Iā€™ve probably spent weeks of real time thinking about all this

1 Like
#24200

canā€™t you design the rooms for murder

1 Like
#24201

Is death city any better

#24202

iā€™m sure thereā€™s oddly specific host ways to kill someone
but those are both uncreative and easy to figure out

1 Like
#24203

Suggested everyone complained

1 Like
#24204

arenā€™t you the host

1 Like
#24205

Death city doesnā€™t have malleable wincons

Itā€™s more like VLDR than dangan

1 Like
#24206

I am making a game for players

1 Like