Cookie Thread Act 2: Silksong

which album are you referring to

but honestly thinking about it i would put marvins’ marvelous circus lower if i listened to the albumn again. i guess its just nostalga

nothing in particular

1 Like

where ya putting are you alright

home odyssey is that grilled cheese album for me. its what got me into music. i did not like music before it. all the songs are. nice.
frankly most albums ive listened to are like all around bangers. i dont have much lukewarm water

1 Like

not sure. im moving igor before Odyssey and probably putting it around care? great album just didnt have any staying power. care and above are things ill relisten to time and time again. except impossible animals i need to tho

1 Like

i think thats solid potitioning for it.

i will say i am almost surprised you questioned me on tally hall before AJR

that is because i dont know what AJR is

1 Like

fair enough.

image

1 Like

fleetwood mac may!

1 Like

solid choice

1 Like

WAIT NO I MISSED THE COOKIE(Bit late reaction, sorry.)

May likes to eat the cookies

1 Like

i never finished listening to 1000 gecs. I should do that

how dare you

1 Like

once youre done witb 1000 gecs u have to listen to 10000 gecs

1 Like

im gonna let you know ive listen to quite a bit of 1000 gecs already and im pretttty sure its going in C. its pretty good but nothing I care about to listen to much. IGOR gets placed in B because there was a time where i was kinda bopping to it but its low B. C is songs that i kinda just chilled to for a bit (except embrace, embrace is a special case being from my wii u era) and didnt go back to and gecs is so that. i enjoy it but i dont fw it that hard.

the mollusk is similar to C except i care about it not at all. i could hold a conversation about the joji album even if i dont remember it very well i could not talk about hte mollusk

FOR THOSE WHO DO NOT KNOW THE MOLLUSK:
it is where this comes from