Cookie Thread Act 4 (Act 5): The Fifth One

General
#5603

i cant believe she’s adding an additional one of each kind of counter of her choice!

1 Like
#5604

fuck you proliferates your time counter

1 Like
#5605

cop with unreliable check and godfather should have the same score they’re the same thing

1 Like
#5606

well one is built-in and one is like
insane cop

1 Like
#5607

people dont like hidden godfathers because of unreliable checks

1 Like
#5608

yeah
its just that one is tied to a different player and one is just a fuck you your role is actively harmful when you think it could be good

1 Like
#5609

i agree that hidden godfathers are :joy_cat: tho

1 Like
#5610

I would argue an unaware insane cop is worse than a godfather. They are not the same thing because the former can produce fake clears and reds. Also a cop has to actually check a Godfather whereas it’s irrelevant who the insane cop checks to produce bad checks. It’s also a role that’s negative utility to the faction, but a GF is at least positive utility for their team. Being fake red checked sucks a lot for both the cop and player being fake red checked (been there). The insane cop is clearly worse from an experience perspective in every way.

3 Likes
#5611

And also suspecting a godfather is at least in the realm of possibility. Suspecting an insane cop just isn’t. The irony is it would be like the literal last thing a sane would assume because of how unusual and obviously unpleasant it is.

2 Likes
#5612

what salt score does this role have nbow

image
image948×517 49.7 KB

3 Likes
#5613

(i’m genuinely curious as to whether you could create a worse role if you tried)

3 Likes
#5614

image
image917×518 15.9 KB

help

1 Like
#5615

pet moment

#5616

this randed to a first time player and through some miracle they ever played again

2 Likes
#5617

a lot of hosts just make games for their own entertainment rather than for the players’ lol

#5618

A literal 5 yeah. Who has fun with this

2 Likes
#5619
#5620

mickey mouse tournament, no elephant

1 Like
#5621

Veteran/PGO is an interesting one. It’s definitely more than 3 but less than 4. I think around a 3.5 but has a much higher salt variance than a Godfather, and is more dangerous to run carelessly, but easier to fix and make less awful.

1 Like
#5622

This is about how I would describe basically anything related to tol yep

1 Like