Curated Grand Idea Discussion Thread

Game Discussion
#21

yeah actually that works

#22

i think its reasonable to submit two roles with slightly different capabilities in the same post, as a sort of “town or mafia” counterpart kind of thing
but we’d need to signify that

#23

like, you don’t want your Town/Mafia inventor to be able to target only mafia with powerful inventions n shit

#24

I was going to have the first post after the OP be that

1 Like
#25

ah that works

#26

Alternatively if you want abilities to change based on alignment you could do

** Fun Invention (Town | Night)** - Give functional invention
Exploding Device (Mafia | Night) - Give nonfunctional invention

Or some shit

2 Likes
#27

oh that feels cool

#28

i think allowing both is optimal

#29

DatBird the Moderator

Town Social
Blue (Passive): You are Blue. This allows you to bypass any silencing, post-restricting, etc. mechanics that are imposed by other roles or game mechanics (but not those imposed by the hosts).
lol you don’t even play anymore friendo (:orange_heart:): You have no day abilities, beyond the ability to post and vote, and cannot gain any by any means.
Review Setup (Night): Choose a role in the Grand Idea Thread. Learn if that role is present in this game. - Infinite Uses
Ban User (Night): Kill target player. - 1 Use

Defeat all members of the Informed Minority and any neutrals that directly oppose your win condition.

DatWolf the Evil Moderator

Mafia Social
Purple (Passive): You have wrestled power from Chloe, becoming Purple. This allows you to bypass any silencing, post-restricting, etc. mechanics that are imposed by other roles or game mechanics (but not those imposed by the hosts). Additionally, once per night, you may anonymously send a message to the thread through the game hosts.
Revise Setup (Night): Choose two roles in the Grand Idea Thread. If the first role is present in the game, all players with that role who are not aligned with your faction will become the second role. - 3 Uses
Silence User (Night): Target player will be able to make a maximum of 50 posts tomorrow. They will be informed of this. - Infinite Uses

Gain parity with the Uninformed Majority and defeat any neutrals that directly oppose your win condition.

1 Like
#30

posting here before posting there

1 Like
#31

yeah this is a banger

1 Like
#32

revise setup cannot go wrong

#33

i honestly completely missed that

#34

it is probably worth letting the host veto roles but yea

#35

yeah

1 Like
#36

4

Eliza

Town/Mafia Investigative
Eliza (passive): You may make a maximum of 50 posts per day phase.
Forum Mafia Political Compass (Town | Day): Quote a player’s post and include a screenshot of exactly one archetype described in the Forum Mafia Political Compass meme. (You must submit a link to the post in your rolecard.) At the end of tonight, learn their role type. If you use this ability, you may not take an action granted to you by your role that night. - Infinite Uses
Forum Mafia Political Compass (Mafia | Day): Quote a player’s post and include a screenshot of exactly one archetype described in the Forum Mafia Political Compass meme. (You must submit a link to the post in your rolecard.) At the end of tonight, learn their exact role. - Infinite Uses
Social Deduction Game Expert (Night): Target a player and name a social deduction game other than Throne of Lies: Medieval Politics or Chair of Deception, such as Untrusted or Blood on the Clocktower. Learn if that player’s role is based on that social deduction game. - Infinite Uses

(Town) Defeat all members of the Informed Minority and any neutrals that directly oppose your win condition.
(Mafia) Gain parity with the Uninformed Majority and defeat any neutrals that directly oppose your win condition.

1 Like
#37

might be best to split the rolecards in two so the hosts can just copy paste it

1 Like
#38

so like

4

town version

5

mafia version

1 Like
#39

yeah

1 Like
#40

yeah sure
town/mafia feels jank now that I’ve played around with it

still want to give people subbing the opportunity to just make 1 role

2 Likes