Agent47: Weird first post. Somehow has knowledge / bias on LW. Later states that it was speculation based on how 3 wolves = too weak and 4 wolves = too strong. (Kinda debatable IMO.)
Arctic: Weird backup on Agent. (Regardless of whether you did it unconsciously or willingly, you did it regardless.) His reason was biased on his last 15’er, except the sample is only 2 games, which should have resulted in a low bias.
Kiiruma: P#28 implies [REDACTED]
, which is NAI but slightly worrisome. I should probably check him out again at D3 if he’s still alive by then.
ATNO: I’m not fond of using RNG to choose scum. I’m slightly interested why he thinks there are 4 wolves, but in retrospect it’s probably safer to make a random POE of 4 players than 3 players.
By the time I am reading Arctic’s P#50, I have decided to throw away my first impression of him, and started to townlean him because of two reasons:
- The same reason why Arete is generally townread as either alignment in every SOD1 of every game I remember: Arctic’s being helpful for the newbies, giving advice about what to do (make transparent posts, do not TR people for AtE, etc.) and what not to do (claim VT/PR).
- Specifically a section in P#50 where he said he didn’t write that post pre-rand. I have read the sentences after that one, and I frankly don’t care. The boldness of the first statement is personally the strongest one I have read in the first 40+ posts, and that is enough to make me townlean him. The others are still null as of moment of writing.
I am not seeing how Kiiruma & Agent are town, nor how Mistyx is mafia, but then again it was less than 1 hour into the game, so I don’t value these reads as much as he does.