Poor Approximations of Catgirls - Thread 1

[Marshal]

Overall marshal thoughts

• arete is ~always mafia. Their posts are wolfy and they have straight up thunderdomed me which is a read I truly do not think town!arete could ever be wrong about.
• arete is unaligned with vulgard. I am basically certain on this one, and this makes vulgard town
• my actual readslist remains otherwise relatively unchanged but

I actually don’t like JC being tied to me this heavily, a tiny little part of me thinks he’s being set up to look like a villager after my villa flip and his pushing outside of me/arete when basically always one of us dies makes me fear i’m going to go out and he’ll be mafia and IC’d. I want to make it clear I think it’s actually quite possible JC and Arete are w/w and he’s not an IC if I go over today.

[nutella]

i’m fully convincing myself of marshal/jc/mist team lmao

[Marshal]

I personally believe wind/wazza look bad in light of an arete flip, especially the latter because of what mist brought up. Look at those two very heavily

[nutella]

@Marshal

I actually don’t like JC being tied to me this heavily, a tiny little part of me thinks he’s being set up to look like a villager after my villa flip and his pushing outside of me/arete when basically always one of us dies makes me fear i’m going to go out and he’ll be mafia and IC’d. I want to make it clear I think it’s actually quite possible JC and Arete are w/w and he’s not an IC if I go over today.

dw i have this in mind too

[Wazza]

Idc which of you two get flipped, I’m still trying to decide who I want to vote

[Wisdom]

There is likely a few wolves in Alana/Nightingale/Mistyx btw

[Wazza]

(It probably won’t be one of you two, atm I’m tempted to vote Night)

[nutella]

wheeee so many preflips and potential universes

[Marshal]

I’m not claiming role or flavor today. It’s entirely irrelevant to whats happening, does not clear me, and we should not give wolves more options wrt anticlaim.

[Marshal]

If I flip today you guys will probably laugh extremely hard

im not taking questions on this post

[Wazza]

Marsha, who do you want to flip?

[Marshal]

Arete.

[Wisdom]

@Marshal

arete is unaligned with vulgard. I am basically certain on this one, and this makes vulgard town

I never understand the reasoning behind these kinds of posts. Why can’t they be v/v?

[Marshal]

ftr I also dislike squirrel being tied to me in this way aswell

A lot of people have taken a frankly super light read on them and acted like they are somehow tied to me or I am vouching for them. I consider squirrel roughly null atp

[Marshal]

Did you read the bullet point above

Arete is mafia
vulgard and arete are not aligned
vulgard is therefore town

[Marshal]

Arctic’s confliction reads as real to me. I highly doubt he is a highposter tied to arete. He stands to gain very little from my flip and is likely town.

[Arctic]

@Wazza

well the contradictory part is the fact he just
didn’t follow the time constraint thing he made, I wouldn’t care about this if it wasn’t for the fake he used this time constraint thing as an argument to not explain where he stands on stuff about the game.

okay that’s actually fair enough

@Wazza

Although. this game you seem confident on your reads, you’re directly full attention onto them and you’re trying to bring people in, comparing it to the game where you led the town, your attitude around your pushes was drastically different, in that game you considered many possibilities, in this game, you’re triggerhappy with your reads as if you’re buying full confidence onto them in a matter of seconds, I’m not a fan of it whatsoever.

i… strongly disagree - after my first few takes i’ve been a lot more shaky on most things. like i dont even know about arete/marshal anymore as an example
what posts in particular made you feel this way?

@Wazza

The point about pushing me for meta reasons is the fact you instantly opened up with talking about how I’m trying to seize thread control, something you notoriously only say when you talk about my meta because you know what I try to do as scum and that’s take over the thread and get thread control, although later on I feel like this is contradicted considering you’ve had to poke me to actually do stuff but meh.

i overextended this read, i’m not going to deny it
i looked at your posts in an iso before i read them in the context of the thread (i saw your jc wall in the thread and that was it) and that made them feel massively more antagonistic than they actually were

@Wazza

Talking about that though, what are your reads on Marshal, Arete and myself? I’m including the first two since I can’t help but feel they’re going to become a vocal point today and I’ll probably get thrown in there at some point for no reason, but also I need to see how your read has developed on me and Marshal specifically.

hoo boy
i’ve answered this in a brief summary since you made this post but here we go again

arete’s focus has been narrow and their posting has been lackluster, lacking the nuance i’d expect from them and creating lines of thought on things i don’t think village them would care about (see: the infamous post on JC “tmislipping”) while ignoring addressing things i believe would actually concern them, but marshal’s approach to me/vul/arete has been wolfy on a macro level with the way in which she changes her reads on me/vulgard for bad reasons which comes across as befitting some sort of agenda, which would be to flip village arete

[Marshal]

I’m going to say final thoughts on LASERpointer later, I promise this, but my final say depends a lot on how the day develops. I think it’s possible they are mafia but if they begin doing mafia things I will say so. As it stands I think they are town.

[Arctic]

@Marshal

I actually don’t like JC being tied to me this heavily, a tiny little part of me thinks he’s being set up to look like a villager after my villa flip and his pushing outside of me/arete when basically always one of us dies makes me fear i’m going to go out and he’ll be mafia and IC’d. I want to make it clear I think it’s actually quite possible JC and Arete are w/w and he’s not an IC if I go over today.

be honest did you just say this because of the discussion on you/jc being a thing lol

[Marshal]

Well yeah, otherwise I wouldn’t have

Tying a wolf as w/w to a villager who is imminently dying is a great way to set up that player as “oh well I guess since [x] was town this guy is just town”