Magnus opum
This is a claim that only a villager makes, generally speaking, since negative utility doesnât want to just be shot. Knowing this design team, itâs probably utilised in a really interesting fashion as wellâŚ
Well, I guess this could be neutral, but Artemis isnât Mafia at least.
Kinda surfacy level read but fine i think? NAI tho
Mayâs ISO is just so awkward without cause. I think Mayâs overwhelmed by the text flourishing so past. w!May presumably wouldnât want to look so awkward right off the bat, but ( 328 ) sorta proves itâs intentional.
Hereâs my very specific review of this nature: May is town unless theyâre precisely evil with Zugzwang. Latching onto another playerâs slot feels iffy.
Magnus why are you so NAI
Iâm not the most fond of this lacklustre progression, actually. Apoâs specifically forming the most level 1 reads instead of simply falling victim to the trap of being overwhelmed in a mash, since neither of these messages are particularly self-aware. I canât remember how Apo usually behaves as either alignment, though Sadbiâs logic regarding Apocryphalâs stiffness seems to be fine.
their posts are just concise without any leaway to be town or wolf read, which makes me believe its wolf??
If I was careless with my reads, Iâd lock Neil in as a villager because of their perspective regarding Firinnâs death ( 1090 ) as an aside-aware gamestate read about basic assumptions (which feels realistically normal), but thereâs nothing unfakeable regarding all their unexplained one-liner reads thus far so Iâm not going to. Thereâs recognisably a position in which Neil could just be evil playing however they feel the most comfortable.
Like they just seem too aware of the posts they make somehow???
@WindwardAway was announced as the king at daystart, and yet she didnât comment on this announcement at all. She couldnât have missed it unless it wasnât her ability (seems unlikely given the nature of the daystart reveal), but she didnât command rule over her subjects in the typical monarch fashion whenever anyone rands King.
Iâm unsure what to make of this.
They make reads but it doesnt lead nowhere (Im likely cutting this in pieces , aka first thread 1 to actually make sense wtf they are doing)
this was said to this
Its like very
Iâm not the greatest fan of his opening, but the way wherein he voted Sadbi at ( #311 ) was clear aggressive RVS, and he then turned it into a rolefishing joke at ( #457 ) which feels like a safe way to force interactions inorganically. Considering that he immediately once again pleaded for a late-night music playlist, this whole early engagement feels abnormal on a first reading. Even his first post, asking if anybody wanted to play Smash Bros, doesnât really make sense in sincerity because he wouldnât have been able to play the game at the same time he was driving.
This isnât even commentary, this is just a reaction post. While Insomnia was voting Sadbi previously to this point, it was for no particular given reason; and he promptly switched off the wagon shortly thereafter without so much as a backwards glance so he wasnât attached to it either.
His Bystander vote was at 914 and elaborated upon at 1256, so if Insomnia found her vote on Brakuren or the starting spectator-like demeanour suspicious, he should have been able to explain the reasoning behind it. Insomnia didnât elaborate on the read whatsoever, and didnât even use it as a way of garnering a conversation from Bystander; ( #1342 ) reveals as much, heâs just attention-baiting.
When questioned about this by Ashlyn, his explanation ( #1482 ) is reflective rather than contemplative; both to justify disliking Bystanderâs initial focus which wouldâve only applied to a single unsubstantiated vote from the first time Insomnia mentioned it, to saying that Brakuren was suspicious for posting recursively to the same person for a short while? That wouldnât innately justify your original findings and it doesnât apply to your own logic, since you arenât calling them W/W? Not even later, when you donât really have an opinion on which one looks worse? Eh.
This whole thing just feels wolfy and unnecessary??? Its just there?
Tutuu town read them and them denying it, read kinda w/w but its magnus they speak in fucking riddles 90% of the time
Either the recursive one-line readers are all town or most of them are evil, with no inbetween. The need to avoid justifying your perspectives either comes from the viewpoint of somebody without the time to express their opinions, or theyâre just taking the easy route since nobodyâs going to follow-up on them.
while true sometimes it feels like just trying to sow discord in the thread
I donât love that Wind wanted to cast doubt on the merits of having her alignment checked before discrediting the announcement. Admittedly, itâs fairly obviously not sincere either way, but at worst it should be nil beside the risk of accidentally getting executed. Wind just seems actively uncomfortable with her votes, which is atypical given the secret double vote claim.
Id have to agree here but it just seems like surface level comments
Conclusion: Marcus is marcus, i really cant get a grasp on them. They seem to only post inflate and just around be there like alexandra but in a better way and not in the afk way.
but also its???