the thing that really bothers me about this is that the soweli/meme/Frink world is like. on the edge of making sense here
ok back
To elaborate on this
I can see w!Soweli trying to shift the wagons onto beancat (whoās confirmed town now), and then changing their mind after T!pandora votes W!Frink
Buuuuuuuut then itās like⦠Meme/Soweli/Frink clearly have enough votes to get beancat over anyway, and then they donāt
And soweli chooses to vote Frink before Meme makes an awkward vote onto beancat
so hhhhhhhhhhhhhh
But also itās like
The vote from Soweli on Frink was a little over a minute before the vote from Meme on Beancat
so I can see a world where wolfchat just failed to coordinate
Actually
I think from my experience in Soweli in Wrogn 2 they didnāt talk in wolfchat much
Soweli not noticing this is⦠IDK what to think about anything this is bad
āforget her⦠and everything she said, she liedā¦ā
somewhat unpairing for pandora/soweli though thatās not a world I thought likely regardless
IDK if this is at all believable as something town wouldnāt know
@Magnus if youāre here thoughts
Mycologist head turn. Youāve forgotten to sign all your posts.
Iāve effectively discounted that individual anomaly because yes, it is bizarre; but Childe also mentioned not knowing how to play the game in the signup thread and itās been a consistent demeanour if so. Basically w!Childe wouldāve been setting up this characterisation from before starting the game if itās made up, or at least swerving too heavily into the act if it started as genuine; whereas v!Childe presumably skimmed the OP, saw āthreeā Mafia, then discounted everything else in the OP which lacked trigger words. Iām saying it could be faked, but it fits consistently into Childeās early behaviour so I canāt really discern alone whether it makes sense to be fabricated. Just sorta drawing an arbitrary line. Actually, Childe possibly just took ājudgment dayā as MELO and didnāt read further if itās genuine⦠hmph.
Mycologist head turn. Youāve forgotten to sign all your posts.
Iāve effectively discounted that individual anomaly because yes, it is bizarre; but Childe also mentioned not knowing how to play the game in the signup thread and itās been a consistent demeanour if so. Basically w!Childe wouldāve been setting up this characterisation from before starting the game if itās made up, or at least swerving too heavily into the act if it started as genuine; whereas v!Childe presumably skimmed the OP, saw āthreeā Mafia, then discounted everything else in the OP which lacked trigger words. Iām saying it could be faked, but it fits consistently into Childeās early behaviour so I canāt really discern alone whether it makes sense to be fabricated. Actually, Childe probably just took ājudgment dayā as MELO,
interesting post
Iām currently at #438 in the reread which is this
On the one hand, mixing up posts from a wolfmate to a villager is odd (ā¦this is admittedly based on my own experience of wolfing and my own mental models of what wolfing is like rather than actual experience, so maybe this is just plainly wrong)
On the other hand they notably find Frink to be a likely wolf and should probably be wary about townreading Meme as a result; Iāll have to note what changes if anything between this and Soweliās eventual vote getting Meme into heaven in the following phase
oh
wonderful draft errors I see

Mycologist head turn. Youāve forgotten to sign all your posts.
ah, I have
Partially because Iām mainly talking to you and myself at this point, but I suppose I will attempt to sign for some clarity if Chomps wishes to read this in detail
-

The question is are we going to get any more developments for this phase of the game. If not why shouldnāt I not hammer if nothing else is going to be added?
this looks very good for pandora
which is⦠not particularly useful but it does let me be a bit more secure in building w!Frink
-

There is also just like who the wolfteam is if not pandora like pandora/childe is an option maybe itās in {meme bean Chomps} but all of them seemed varying degrees of fine, which makes that the average position of a player and thus towny so I donāt know.

wait nvm i was attributing meme posts to chomps in my head. I still donāt think heās particularly wolfy but making a counterwagon to a likely wolf is not a good look. Still overall like his posts but probably less than those other two.
I do want. beancat in particualr to post more so I can be more confident in that read but I also think everybody should post more.
hhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
well the issue here is that W!Frink looks bad on all of beancat/chomps/meme so itās not indefensible for Soweli to then vote meme later
- As usual
Currently I think Soweli makes the most sense as the wolf
Because Meme distancing from Childe in the way they did feels⦠very risky if theyāre w/w
Thereās a high risk Childe got sent to Hell during Hell Phase 3 as a result of the way Meme was playing, whichād lose for wolves
-
I do think that if Soweliās the wolf, Iāve been underestimating them as a result of Wrogn 2
I do remember them mentioning in that wolfchat that they wont a 11v2 mountainous (note the non-standard numbers) in Wrogn 2 wolfchat so maybe that was simply an offgame from them
-
readthrough completed
I have yet to ISO Soweli and Childe to find if their progressions make sense
A bizarre progression was the reason I caught Meme during Hell 2 so hopefully that can make things clear again here
-
I have to go now
Iāll be back soon
@Chomps weāll need your vote here to outvote Meme
If possible Iād like to finish analyzing before we vote
If you have to go offline for the night I would vote Soweli
-