Forum Avalon - Resistance Win!

[Hippopablompoyeetus]

@Kiiruma

@Marluna I’d be down for a team of something like me, you, Hip and Childe. Could sub Childe for something like Leafia or Frost or Chomps.

my current theory is that this is just me and the three group mafia haha

[Kiiruma]

Therefore you’ve shown that you have 0 mechanical reason to be pushing against me and Node 1 whatsoever and it’s just because you’re evil

[Kiiruma]

Jarek’s outed as evil.

[Jarek]

This is legitimately starting to get on my nerves

[Hippopablompoyeetus]

wdym?

[Kiiruma]

Next time read the OP before you try and lie.

[Jarek]

If you don’t want to listen, and you want to call me evil, then do whatever you want. I was looking forward to actually playing this game without having to explain SIMPLE GAME LOGIC to people.

[Jarek]

I.
Do.
Not.
Care.
About.
The.
Roles.

[Kiiruma]

Jarek:

@Jarek

The main point to me being correct here is that you’re acting like you know I’m not merlin. You should not be distrusting me simply because I’m questioning a proposition. I very well could be merlin who knows that prop was evil and is trying to do something about it. Making me have to explain myself invites me, as a merlin, to trip up and out that I know too much

---

Also Jarek:
Literally doesn’t bother reading how Merlin’s card works.
Or Gawain’s.
Or Pervical’s.

[Jarek]

You haven’t listened to a fucking word I’ve said

[Kiiruma]

If you’re good Jarek you can and should be caring about how the fucking roles work.
But you’re showing that you don’t.

[Jarek]

I don’t give a fuck about how the roles work because on NUMEROUS OCCASIONS

NUMEROUS

[Marluna]

@Jarek

I.
Do.
Not.
Care.
About.
The.
Roles.

literally the guy who said this 30 minutes ago…:

@Jarek

You sound like either gawain or morgana

So which is it?

[Jarek]

I have actively compared this game to a simpler game called mindnight that I will continue to compare this to because it is the only thing I know that fits the glove

[Hippopablompoyeetus]

Ok how about we do me/kiiruma/marluna/icet and then if we get it wrong we force icet to use it on someone else in the group to try get a 1v1

[Jarek]

Mindnight has evil and good and nothing else, this role business is a spanner in the works that I can’t quite figure out how it works

[Kiiruma]

Bingo.

[Jarek]

It doesn’t change literally anything for me other than a few good players know another good player and evils do some things too. The core of the game, and what I am discussing is that if there is an evil player in any given proposition they do not have to out themselves and instantly fail it. They CAN play along because it’s beneficial to them to hide

[Marluna]

Didn’t we agree that not let Icet on the mssion, which might fail?

[Hippopablompoyeetus]

Yeah it’s like secret hitler.

Thing is I do know I am good and was leader first and Kiiruma makes a decent point that if the first one we failed we would lose a lady of the lake thing, but it didn’t fail. Which means we get an extra lady of lake which is pretty big. If I was evil there I’d definately just fail it, I’ve got 3 other evils anyway.

Like game mech wise if exactly 1 out of u 3 is evil I think it is always right to fail in that scenario. Which makes me think that it might be both Childe and Kiiruma, because it makes way way less sense to fail that scenario if there are 2.