It would be less of a contradiction and more of a eureka, “that applies to you too” moment.
In my head it was ‘the contradiction is you shouldn’t even NEED to ask this. BAM’
Well anyway that was fun. Going to go work on other things and maybe do isos with fresh eyes tomorrow because clearly I need it.
Top town and wolf reads btw, 3 of each.
1 Like
That’s crazy tbh regardless yesterday I never vote someone who looks like a newb if they’re being voted for “small posts; being cringe”
I have so many thoughts but im so hesitant rn tbh 
TR: Achro, May and… huh. I’m not entirely who else to put here.
SR: Squid, Epitau, maybe Kanave? Could put Min here instead, I guess.
Who are your reads?
Man, I’m having trouble reading this game, even after looking back. There really were no wrong options for scum with that Pigeon wagon, since it seemed pretty obvious the whole time that it would be Pigeon getting voted out (and even if it wasn’t, that Pigeon would be voted out soon). I’ll take some of the blame for that - I started the wagon, I didn’t encourage a counterwagon until someone else started it, and I should have switched back to Pigeon later - but it’s certainly not all my fault.
On the wagon, they’re with the majority of people and get a townie voted out - one that seemed so scummy that it’s not at all odd to have voted them. Off the wagon, they get to avoid having gone with a townie execution. I’m a bit at a loss for reads, honestly. Can we just vote mafia so that they have some level of pressure to do one thing or another? Please? Thanks 
2 Likes
How did you feel when Pigeon flipped Town? Are you surprised by Apo dying and flipping as villager?
- Mistyx - light town
- Achromatic - light town
- Jaiden -
- Leafia - townread
- Eliza - null (yet I find villagery solely because I felt anxious at people willing to vote them immediately)
- Magnus - nullscum but probably not with zorvo
- May - nulltown
- PoisonedSquid - nullscum
- epitau - null
- Zorvo - nullscum but probably not with magnus
- Kanave - nullscum
why do I scumread most of the game
Idk I really can’t think
So many of y’all have pingy posts
1 Like
What does this mean?
Strats
I wanted jaiden to
Keep vibing ngl
I’ve been expecting like, at least some posts from them regarding eod
I wasn’t too surprised by Pigeon flipping town - I gave it a 40% chance to happen before the flip, and honestly, that was a little bit of a lowball, as I was definitely still a little stuck in tunnel brain. I feel a little dumb about staying the Pigeon course so long, TBH. I don’t think I was really right about it being a great information vote, and their posts kept reminding me of misvotes I’ve pushed in the past, at least toward the end of the day phase. They weren’t arguing like someone who has buddies. Ah well, you win some, you lose some, and it would’ve been irresponsible to let Pigeon go, given the decent chance that they were scum.
Apo dying… gonna be honest, I keep conflating Achro and Apo, and so it’s hard for me to remember super well, but I know I had a townread on Apo; her opinions always seemed expressed in a way that was natural to me. I wouldn’t say I was particularly surprised.
2 Likes
I’m playing a really scientific mafia game where I scroll to a random place in the thread and start reading. I landed on this post, which reads odd to me. I happen to know, at least in retrospect, that these main two wagons (Pigeon and I) were town v town (thanks to incredible strat “viewing my own role card”). This is the sort of thing that I think scum would say in that sort of scenario - distancing yourself from the main wagons for towncred later. This was also directly after Achro stated that the non-voters (including Eliza) were suspicious. Hmm.
2 Likes
1 Like
VOTE: Jaiden
Everyone is welcome to read the ISO I just read and disagree with me. I feel like Misty at least feels confident when interacting with me, which I think is is usually town. I know she’s going to be busy today and if I paranoia’d onto an early town read and she got lynched because she was busy I’d be really annoyed with myself.
@May I just played against wolf Eliza last game and so far she has more coherent posts than she does there, but also I am told she is very hard to read as either alignment and as wolf last game she kind of dived into mechanics super hard. It wouldn’t be one for one though. Also how many people conflated me and apoc what the heck lol x)
I feel like… I have barely read anything from Squid past that one big post I looked at. I don’t remember them at all. Huh. I’ll try to amend that sometime today.
also @min @Magnus both of you having that many wolf reads/lack of town reads is so weird. Here I am with only a few good leans and a lot of town leans and you guys are like ‘trust no one’ x)
I can’t help but feel that’s a little motivated somewhere.
It’s actually a lack of motivation tbh Lmao
1 Like
Damnit min every time i look at you funny you say something that completely disarms me lol
But seriously try to be a little less paranoid. Turn two of those reads into townleans. Even if it is a whisper of a guess. Just post your reasoning it isnt binding x)
I promise I’ll fo it in the morning bc I agree, I need less scumreads