[Game Thread] Morbtainado - Morbfia EPIC win

[min]

extreme

[Magnus]

I wasn’t paying much attention to the Pigeon wagon.

[Achromatic]

Oh, I wasn’t saying May was being opportunistic, I thought the issue there was why would May think that Pigeon was being opportunistic when I thought May laid out decent reasons to suspect Leafia and Pigeon was agreeing, but then May didn’t really give much thoughts as to what changed.

[Game Thread] Morbtainado - Day 1 14/14

I think being wrong on the internet is a key tenant of social deduction games, but it’s fair to be wary of it, I guess. Refusing to make your own points does make you much harder to analyze in general, and if your points are bad, people just… won’t listen to them, and won’t vote that way.

Her last post to pigeon before voting pigeon didn’t feel like she thought Pigeon was being motivated. Just harder to solve. Maybe that is wolfy to May and I’ve love to hear more thoughts there.

[epitau]

@Magnus

Pigeon threw out an accusation some people didn’t like.

hmmm. alright, anything else i should know?

[Magnus]

@May

Leafia’s posts seem strange to me, though I am not experienced in the art of Poasting around here. It feels like it’s intended to throw confusion around - this post I’m replying to creates a weird connection that could mess up anyone retroactively analyzing their behavior after an evil flip. VOTE: Leafia

Voting Leafia due to her “claiming” wolf. I played a game where a Mafia member claimed as such and everyone just assumed “a wolf wouldn’t claim wolf” and let them live, so I can’t disagree with May’s vote here.

[ElizaThePsycho (Willow)]

No

[Achromatic]

I’d suggest reading through the game and trying to form your own opinions.

[Magnus]

I’m guessing you aren’t inclined to read through 700 posts since you’re asking for a TL;DR, right?

[epitau]

i probably should but it seems not ideal

[Magnus]

@May

He said he was interested in consolidating vote trains, and provided no further information

@May

Actually, you know what, VOTE: thepigeonnyc due to his many high crimes and misdemeanors (bad vibes + opportunism)

This could go either way.

[Magnus]

Here’s an idea. What if you specifically read the posts of one player and shared your opinion on them? You can isolate posts with the person button in your menu.

[Apocryphal]

May wagon is… interesting, but seeing how little she(?) has posted, I don’t really feel that invested in it.

I’d rather be on the pigeon side of a Pigeon/May wagon formation tbh

Someone ping me in a few hours to make a decision because I’m not going to be here for EoD, as stated when the day started.

[Apocryphal]

Also, epitau’s entrance is… underwhelming to say the least.

[Achromatic]

Do you think running up one player and no one else day one is the best way to play a day one?

[Apocryphal]

Oh fuck no.

I just feel nothing about May, while I actually do feel something about pigeon but voting early is for scrubs.

If things don’t change much by the time I wake up tomorrow, I’ll probably just vote May though.

[Apocryphal]

Everyone make your bets as to whether or not I can make forty some-odd posts in less than two hours tomorrow before I have to leave for work

That said, good night everyone.

[epitau]

mmm, alright

[Achromatic]

Keep in mind I am the only one voting May, she’s not even a wagon I just saw her lack of content and she is the only one on the Pigeon wagon who hasn’t been posting much now that min is starting to check in so I thought it was a good place to explore.

Pigeon is at 5 votes already when it’s 8 to swing, so I feel like a vote for pigeon is a vote for praying to god pigeon is wolf and little else.

[epitau]

i concur :)

[Apocryphal]