GOAT^2 - Game Thread (5/15) - Day 6 - Mafia wonnered

[ElizaThePsycho (Willow)]

pls

[ElizaThePsycho (Willow)]

I am being REPLACED by an INFERIOR version who DOESN’T APPRECIATE THE ART

[ElizaThePsycho (Willow)]

(help I’m going to have an actual identity crisis over this)

[KingTroll]

@people in game

i got town in my rolecard so i’m confirmed
ybw is extremely likely town right now. however if neither of us dies by like d5 my wifom “what if i’m being heavily pocketed” instincts will kick in
BradLand should solve the game like i’ve been informed they can
ElizaThePsycho is mehhhh. even without marl wanting them out i don’t think they should survive into the lategame
Lemonfairy is alright honestly because i recognize their feelings as town
Magnus i feel like would be dead by now if they were right
May is mmmm their d1 case on me now i dunno chiefs
mollylikesorigami could potentially be tmi or a good town player but they aren’t dead so
illwei still hasn’t made that much of a presence for themselves i feel like i should’ve gotten them over marl yesterday
Vulgard is town 90% of the time
Zorvo is town so often

okay

[KingTroll]

i suppose i can stop liking every post. and just. leave some gray and alone and heartless

[Lemonfairy]

@May

Everyone’s assignment for tonight is to post their top 3 townreads. It would also be nice if you could analyze what you think of your townreads’ reads - do you think they’re accurate, inaccurate, something in between, would you vote with them, and why?

this might actually be a good exercise
I think my top 3 TRs are still Vul, Zorvo, Troll

Troll just dropped new reads
nice

@Vulgard

I townread kt, am reconsidering may but not really reaching any conclusions (I feel like they’re barely playing the game but that fact seems nai), I think ybw has been villagery and definitely more villagery than Magnus but if I’m misreading Magnus then maybe I should look there

I think Brad is pretty comfortably town

I also TR Troll
May, I think could go either way but I’d like to think they’re town and will solve the game by like D5
though admittedly, I don’t love May’s reads
YBW idk I think they’ve made some very towny posts but my love for thinking that there are deepwolves makes me want to scumread the slot (and out of people who I think are making an impact on game and look to be solving, this is the slot I TR the least). I don’t really like the push on Eliza.
idk about Brad

@Zorvo

Lemon, Brad, Silviu, Molly and Magnus are all town.

Zorvo’s read on me is correct
idk about Brad
Illwei, I am also unsure on
Molly, I am trying not to OMGUS-tunnel and evaluate fairly
Magnus, I kind of TL for being not associated with O.kazo

@KingTroll

ybw is extremely likely town right now. however if neither of us dies by like d5 my wifom “what if i’m being heavily pocketed” instincts will kick in
BradLand should solve the game like i’ve been informed they can
ElizaThePsycho is mehhhh. even without marl wanting them out i don’t think they should survive into the lategame
Lemonfairy is alright honestly because i recognize their feelings as town
Magnus i feel like would be dead by now if they were right
May is mmmm their d1 case on me now i dunno chiefs
mollylikesorigami could potentially be tmi or a good town player but they aren’t dead so
illwei still hasn’t made that much of a presence for themselves i feel like i should’ve gotten them over marl yesterday
Vulgard is town 90% of the time
Zorvo is town so often

I’m struggling to make sense of these
YBW, I’ve expressed my doubts on
I feel like Brad is getting a pass for being known for being good at solving as town
I’m confused about the read on Magnus (are you saying they’re town? scum? or that they’re just wrong? does wrong imply town?)
May idk either
agree Vulgard is probably just town
pretty sure Zorvo is town

[Lemonfairy]

idk what I got from doing that
I feel like I haven’t figured out anything from it

[Lemonfairy]

Vul/Zorvo/Troll
Eliza
May/Brad
Magnus/Illwei
YBW
molly

ew I don’t like these but I’ll post them anyway
I’m ok with Eliza and above but I don’t really believe in the order below that

[Vulgard]

@Lemonfairy

I want to see more from May

i’ve wanted to see more from may for two whole days and they haven’t delivered
that’s part of the reason i’m worried i’m misclearing them

[Vulgard]

@people in game

BradLand should solve the game like i’ve been informed they can

who told you that

[Vulgard]

@Lemonfairy

May, I think could go either way but I’d like to think they’re town and will solve the game by like D5

they aren’t even trying to do that right now they’re just posting exercises and they posted a fake-looking read on kt day 1 that they later insisted was real and didn’t draw any conclusions from people’s responses to it

[Vulgard]

@Lemonfairy

I feel like Brad is getting a pass for being known for being good at solving as town

for me it’s less that and more that he didn’t literally 10-post and openwolf under suspicion

[Vulgard]

@Lemonfairy

I’m confused about the read on Magnus (are you saying they’re town? scum? or that they’re just wrong? does wrong imply town?)

i think the read is saying magnus is town
though the perspective on it is weird

[KingTroll]

someone said it d1 and i’m not going back to check

[Vulgard]

whoever said it doesn’t know brad
brad himself literally said he doesn’t know how to find scum, only town

[Vulgard]

that’s why you don’t read him by whether he’s solving the whole game but by how he’s finding and treating his townreads

[KingTroll]

oh in that case brad goes straight into my poe then

[Host_Account_1]

mollylikesorigami (3): Vulgard, KingTroll, May
ElizaThePsycho (2): YoubutWorse, Zorvo
Zorvo (2): Illwei, BradLand

Not Voting (4): ElizaThePsycho, Lemonfairy, Magnus, mollylikesorigami

[Vulgard]

@Lemonfairy

idk what I got from doing that
I feel like I haven’t figured out anything from it

if you mean may’s exercise then idk what it’s supposed to accomplish either

[Vulgard]

@Lemonfairy

I looked through Illwei ISO (because I only was looking at Silviu before)
and idk it looks ok

it’s not like a fountain of towniness but I see some unique takes
like scumreading Zorvo
and earlier not trusting Vulgard and scumreading May

the problem is we’re super easy people to cast doubt on but i also feel like we’ve been obvious town
me and zorvo at least
but zorvo torpedoes his credibility every time he tries to argue a read and i’m a popular suspicion target

so these reads don’t do anything for me in terms of “this is spicy and anti-consensus, might be town”

see htf where i buried a wolf d1 and me being on a town wagon d2 prompted two highposting villas to iso me and one of them wolfcased me while i was getting nightkilled