GOAT^2 - Game Thread (5/15) - Day 6 - Mafia wonnered

[Marluxion]

I also commented on it earlier

[Marluxion]

It could go either way, I’m not convinced on the spew side and both players are wolfier than normal

[Magnus]

Killing LHF early, in case they’re evil, so they aren’t problematic later if they’re alive at XYLO or something?

[Vulgard]

idk about magnus anymore
sorry for not being that into the game, my activity is always lower on weekends

[Vulgard]

I think I need to re-evaluate a bit

[Magnus]

Enjoy your weekend.

[Vulgard]

UNVOTE

I still don’t think you should kill Marl but I’ll re-read some things

[Marluxion]

vulgard it is literally impossible to reason with these people
just set a poe for them to follow when we’re both dead and if they dont listen it’s on them

just
as an example
seth thinks i’m scum because ???
lemonfairy has not said why they think i’m scum
eliza thinks i’m scum for reasons they had but they can’t remember
may thinks i’m scum from literal falsities in their solving that i responded to and rebutted but my responses ‘lacked substance’ and ‘didn’t warrant acknowledging’
lol thinks i’m null implying none of my 300 exclusively content posts are alignment indicative

that is what we are dealing with here
just accept me dying and literally spell out the path for them to win the game after
if they dont follow if, that is entirely on them
they cant literally all be scum
most likely scum i still think is ybw/lemon/may
illwei should die before any of them imo though

[Vulgard]

@Marluxion

most likely scum i still think is ybw/lemon/may
illwei should die before any of them imo though

i like this as i’m reading this right now
what about brad
there’s something about brad that makes me think he’s more likely town but i can’t say

[Vulgard]

i think kingtroll has been excessively towny the entire game and if he’s a wolf then i’m not going to find him

the way he shifts between worlds and organically develops his reads and how he pivots from one player to another while clearly re-evaluating instead of just being opportunistic or switching for bullshit reasons (or both) goes beyond a wolf’s capacity to fake in my opinion

wolves can be like “i’ll push anywhere i want” but i think kt is too organic with it to be faking it

[Marluxion]

his reaction to me thinking he wasn’t town cleared yet at sod is near identical to another game on MU where he did the same thing

i’m trying to find it but i can’t
@BradLand knows what game i’m talking about though i’m pretty sure

[Vulgard]

was he a wolf in that game

[Lemonfairy]

@BradLand

would mafia be that blatant talking about not reading the thread

well I’ve read the thread now
and I was technically talking about reading the thread, not not reading it

ew double negative

also what’s with the vote and unvote?

[Lemonfairy]

talk to me then
anything you feel is wrong with my reads (aside from uh thinking you/Marl is the solve lol)?

[Lemonfairy]

@Marluxion

lemonfairy has not said why they think i’m scum

why don’t you ask or talk to me?

[Marluxion]

no he was town and also got himself banned after which is why he should remember
i dont remember if he was on an alt or not though, i can’t find the game

we were both town

[Vulgard]

@Marluxion

we were both town

okay

i feel like brad’s sheer postcount clears him actually but i also think his solving is fine

Solveposts I liked

@BradLand

@May

Basically, if Zorvo is wolf, probably a wolf in Brad/Vulgard. If Brad is wolf, probably at maximum one wolf in Zorvo/YBW, but those two easily could be V/V. All very early, subject to change.

Feel like you’re stretching way too hard to try to find preflip connections with this because it’ll cause more mistakes read wise, although it’s probably just a train of thought that you’re continuing which looks fine in a vacuum.

@BradLand

@Marluxion

Also I don’t wanna be that guy but the instant Brad froze and tried to play a townread he gave off as a joke he became basically lock w

Marl you need to take context into what was going on.

That point in the game was a batch of nothing with Vulgard trying to scum hunt in the middle of it.
Then came a point where the game was literally just you, Vulgard, and lol posting, which literally isn’t the ideal point to solve there; which also devolved into lol just posting memes.

@BradLand

Do you have anything else for me? Feels like you’re trying to stretch for reasoning here in hopes you have something but in reality you don’t believe it because you know it isn’t true.

@BradLand

Confusing legacy actually.

And he ended with his vote on Magnus.

But I feel like Magnus is towny…

Am I doing something wrong?

@BradLand

Okay I’m seeing Vulgard and KT’s takes on Lemon, dropping her out of my town list until I see her posting.

Then I’ll force her back onto my town list because I need to slam my head into the wall more and be a detriment to myself and others.

@BradLand

I went off on YBW at EOD because she was trying to put me in connection with Kazo despite me literally saying I was fine with those 2 being wagons, I said Kazo’s iso was bad and I had my reasons, I had my reasons to scumread Silviu as well, plus I had my scumread and vote on him in the middle of the day and it would’ve been a nice confidence boost if I manage to be right and it went over with my help.

Plus I feel like I’ve been towny as fuck throughout day 1, like I didn’t spend as much time in the game as much as I’d want to, but if you literally look at my iso I’m making my solve attempts.

This sequence as well (maybe w/w with marl if i stretch it but i think marl is town so lmao)

@BradLand

Really doesn’t matter who had you as a wolf, you’re misreading me when you shouldn’t be.

@BradLand

Did you read my entire day 1?

@BradLand

Like you’re saying yesterday when I was out the house most of that day. I did what I did when I was here most of Day 1.

@BradLand

You’re lying by saying this, then saying I did nothing.

@BradLand

This is entirely bullshit and you’re discrediting what I did day 1. I had my joke reads when nothing was going on, then when the game got serious I got my reads.

@BradLand

Cool, in that case if you’re not reading me right, then you are a wolf.

VOTE: Marluxion

@BradLand

If you’re town then learn your fucking lesson, read me correctly.

@BradLand

You should be calling me town.

@BradLand

VOTE: Unvote

Might’ve overreacted but getting annoyed with not being townread when I deserve it lately.

@BradLand

The thing that was also struck me off reading his iso was that his post voting Kazo is like… the jarring sentence that comes in after voting Kazo, talking about something completely different.

@BradLand

Relatively same thing but the second post add Vulgard in it.

Talks about me and Silviu dichotomy.

Then talking about Kazo without reasons he could be maf.

yeah i mentioned this before but i still think i need to re-read him

i’m comfortable calling brad town aorn

[Lemonfairy]

@Vulgard actually, your initial wall on Marl played a part in my scumread on them
why do you think they’re town now?

I know you said something about their reaction to your push is towny but fmpov Marl’s reaction actually looked worse for them

[Magnus]

@Lemonfairy

why don’t you ask or talk to me?

Burden of proof shouldn’t be on the defence.

[Marluxion]

most of the time you post when i’m not around, sorry
you didn’t really say anything i had a comment on
if you want to talk about your scumread on me i’ll be here for another 10m or so
and then away until around 11