Last poster before threadlock gets a cookie (cookie thread (Part 7)) (Part 8)

the joseph anderson streams did unimaginable damage to my speech patterns when talking about p4 and p5

2 Likes

the cake knight rises is PEAK

I think the useless sequence is bad because they flashback to a scene that happened in the same train of cutscenes
I don’t think you could save between the scenes

3 Likes

he’ll ruin p3r for you too soon enough

1 Like

It’s ~fine but on the nose otherwise
I’m fine with on the nose

relevant

1 Like

honestly tho the priestess arcana confidant in P5R was such a missed opportunity for a rewrite

imagine if it subverted our expectations and actually the friend was in the right and we saw actual growth after being wrong

could have been great

1 Like

priestess absolutely deserved a rewrite
I think it’s the weakest of the non-auto party links by a pretty wide margin

1 Like

silly orange, the persona series isn’t allowed to be meaningfully subversive!

1 Like

100%

progressive series with the most conservative writer

2 Likes

that’s cap as fuck

I have never been gaslit harder by a game in my entire life than Royal

1 Like

I can’t really get into details without heavy spoilers but I was shook

1 Like

generational mindfuckery

on par with higurashi gou’s first arc

1 Like

p5r third semester is genuinely top tier content in the jrpg space
10/10 stuff which isn’t something I give out lightly

2 Likes

100% agree

which makes all of the other issues I have with Royal feel very worth it in the end

1 Like

p4g winter dungeon clearly better i can’t believe you support the dogshit 3rd semester when you could have peak

2 Likes

I have changed my opinion about the answer

2 Likes

third semester doesn’t have a single line as good as “only people have human rights”

6 Likes

ok yeah real

1 Like