Last poster before threadlock gets a cookie (cookie thread (Part 7)) (Part 8)

General
#29201

no
it’s just that

2 Likes
#29202

…huh. I see.
By the way, you forgot the role number.

2 Likes
#29203

hmm okay i will change that one too i didn’t cook

2 Likes
#29204

goon is a broken role it can just be bussed (instant win for mafia on fol)

1 Like
#29205

In the case the host thinks a role is irrepairably broken the common consensus I saw in past Grand idea games, that it will simply rerolled. (And removing that slot from the list.)

Or in one case, the host just flat out announced for which roles they won’t roll, even before the rand.

3 Likes
Grand Idea Thread - Moderated
#29206

it would simply not be put into the game

1 Like
Grand Idea Thread - Moderated
#29207

Why, though?
I’m pretty sure Gim has a lot of insta-win roles with less effort behind them.
(With this, you still need to eliminate most of the mafia team, and you still need to stay alive.)

#29208

it’s not that it’s too powerful
it’s this:

1 Like
#29209

why are you numbering them wrong. smh

#29210

i feel as though the host will ignore it anyways

#29211

I numbered them properly in Roman Numerals and in Japanese. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

#29212

I feel as though your roles will be ignored when randing

#29213

and also be ignored by everyone else posting to the thread

#29214

So basically just like any other roles I created.
Don’t worry. I’m used to it.

#29215

no as in your role will cause actual numbering issues which is not good for GI thread

#29216

Eh. I doubt it. OP would’ve changed otherwise.

It’s been 3 years and nobody screws up in the given 400+ posts? If there was none before, then I don’t mind being the first.

1 Like
#29217

exactly once and i think we fixed it

#29218

either way do not intentionally do it!!

#29219

i knew everything was too good yesterday the world decided to get back at me by giving me a sudden scare on my dream

1 Like
#29220

I think the consensus that me and Amelia are going for here is that if a role is fundamentally broken slight tweaks will be made

Not gonna sit there and remake every role, obviously, but if a role is unspecified or unclear on what it does, we’ll make a slight edit to make it clearer

I’m not the moderator of the thread tho, GI ain’t been moderated for a long time :joy_cat:

Best way I’d describe it is that if there’s a role like lying darkness, it’s getting rerolled, no editing necessary, it’d be stupid to include it, but if there’s a role that has unspecified interactions like when a Squire takes up a mantle of a role, is it instant or at the end of the night? Unspecified, we’ll change it slightly instead of skipping from the role

3 Likes