Last poster before threadlock gets a cookie (cookie thread (Part 7)) (Part 8)

General
#22712

you should play civ 3

#22713

image
image1816×587 80.1 KB

from the games I’ve played here that aren’t your games:

4 town wins
8 mafia wins

thtbthbthbth IMO I like where your games are balanced at
this is partially because I think it’s more interesting to be in a bad spot as town but nya I think this is a reasonable town winrate

1 Like
#22714

Nintendo Loop Mafia

2 Likes
#22715

Eh I think I’d prefer a slightly higher town winrate because it makes mafia wins feel more satisfying, it feels kind of meaningless pulling off a close win as mafia when ~80% of games are mafia wins, because that means you did worse than the average wolfteam

3 Likes
#22716

i’d prefer people to play better in games

2 Likes
#22717

town has a skill isuue

1 Like
#22718

^ town’s skill issue

2 Likes
#22719

Stealing this template.

1 Like
#22720

this is a BAD template you should steal May’s template instead

#22721

My understanding is that May’s thing is a pivot table?

#22722

there’s pivot tables but also a full list

1 Like
#22723

@May, nyaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa.

#22724

i think most people would have fun with a 50% winrate. balancing unique setups is hard. commonly played setups on other sites like mu are not commonly played here

2 Likes
#22725

except me. i will lord the 100% winrate until we rand mafia together in 5 monthish

2 Likes
#22726

i attribute some of my town losses to the setup being >scumsided than the average of say cop13er or mountainous 9v2. but i also attribute some of my town wins to the setup being >townsided

1 Like
#22727

i think this is the case with most people who don’t just play setups that have been run over and over

2 Likes
#22728

(for the record this absolutely wouldn’t stand if i played on somewhere like mu but. when you all have the same easy way to pull one over on you it’s not too hard to win)

this is mostly shown by the wolfgames that i’ve played here: only one wasn’t a sweep, and in that one only one mafia member died. another would’ve died if town just asked for claims on what they knew was final day

#22729

jeez i feel like i’m there now. it feels weird

the game feeling too easy/out of my hands is one of the main reasons i don’t play mafia much

#22730

i mean for goodness sake i spent all of fam4 compiling mechanics 72 people were claiming cause i had nothing better to do besides wait to see if the people i suspected died in itas

1 Like
#22731

No need to sweat. There are new and fun roles in Grand Ideas thread,